The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #9589   Message #4111113
Posted By: leeneia
23-Jun-21 - 09:39 AM
Thread Name: Origins: riddle song (I Gave My Love a Cherry)
Subject: Lyr Add: I HAVE A YONG SUSTER
Here's a text from "One Hundred Middle English Lyrics". Robert D. Stevick, editor. Poem is c. 1430

I have a yong suster [sister] fer biyonde the see;
many ben the drueries [gifts] that she sente me.

She sent me the chery wythouten any ston
And so she dide the dowve [dove] withouten any bon.

She sente me the brere [rose branch, briar?] withouten any rynde [bark]
She bad [bade] me love my lemman [sweetheart] wythouten longynge.

How sholde any chery ben wythouten ston?
And how sholde any dowve ben wythouten bon?

How sholde any brere ben wythouten rynde?
How sholde I love my lemman wythouten longynge?

When the chery was a flour, than hadde it non ston.
Whan the dowve was an ey, [egg] than hadde it non bon.

Whan the brere was unbred [was a seed] than hadde it non rynde.
Whan the mayden hath that she loveth, she is wythouten longynge.

==============
The editor notes that this is a unique text, but such paradoxes are common.