The problem with using a guest login, Nick, is that you can only post above the line, meaning that the topic has to be about music. The other issue is that anonymous trolls then also have access and anything remotely controversial will attract a fair few of those. Sadly :-( I can see that your original post was well meant and, if I remember rightly, you were implying that the work of artists, like MacColl and others, who write about the plight of travelling folk was wasted if people like Carr are still making light of it.