Scotland already has a (somewhat) separare set of laws and devolution in Holyrood. Are you saying one of your optuons is to scrap all that, to have all rule from Westminster.

Why should Scotland have devolved powers any more than, say, the Yorkshire and Humber Region, which has about the same population. Greater London has about the same population as Scotland and Wales put together. Separate laws for all the the regions would lead to mayhem.

The other option, to sink or swim on their own, is better than the mish-mash we have now.

DC