The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #172433   Message #4173504
Posted By: GUEST,GUEST
31-May-23 - 04:09 AM
Thread Name: Tune Add: Mystery of the Missing Jig
Subject: RE: Tune Add: Mystery of the Missing Jig
ok,some constructive critricism
it is alright, but I have no inclination to play it, I find the two parts too similiar,
here is a suggestion listen to a lot of tunes analyse chord structures , imo some of the best jigs like the Hags Purse, have different feel between the two parts.
Another example of a tune with two contrasting part a is Chief O NIELLS HORNPIPE, where the second part goes to an f major chord or the galway hornpipe which has an intersting chord PROGRESSION at rhe beginning of the turn
imo it is a fairly average composition, nothing that grabs me and makes me want to play it