it is not a question of better it is a question of being accurate .I think you are right, a lot of us went and sought out material from the uk, but it was not exclusively down to MacColl,in fact it was the idea of Lomax Cyril Tawney had a different approach he went to singers and said i have found this song which would really suit you, a more subtle approach and imo more successful. A number of people including Bert encouraged younger singers to look up our own geographical british isles material [including Ireland]of songs, instead of singing american material. I thanked Gibb and think his post was very good. Black Acorn scoring points is negative and does not contribute to good overall discussion