Steve Gardham,
I am entitled to disagree, without being insulted.
I have not been convinced by Roberts arguments, you have not authority to tell me" I am out of my depth", you do not know how much reading, I have done on the subject of traditional song over the course of 50 years involvement.but it is considerable
".It would be helpful to casual readers here if after giving your opinion you add something like, 'BUT I haven't done any research on the matter."'
quote steve gardham
your comment is uninformed and inaccurate