The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #173554   Message #4209963
Posted By: GUEST,Phil d'Conch
16-Oct-24 - 07:02 PM
Thread Name: Pamphlet: The Singing Englishman (A.L. Lloyd)
Subject: RE: Pamphlet: The Singing Englishman (A.L. Lloyd)
Yes, Bert was 1937 according to Bert. I've seen nothing else anywhere to support or contradict that... except folks going from memory and not from Bert.

Neither have I seen anything to suggest chanties were collected as work song on the Southern Empress. Hugill collected a Davies forebitter/demo at home and shelved it under "sea-going" chantey. Standard genre label convention even today.

On topic, I'm still trying to find out what A.L. Lloyd's own words/claims were. 'Learned' or 'heard' might work for song collecting... validating a work practice, not so much.