The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #174525   Message #4232281
Posted By: Doug Chadwick
29-Nov-25 - 09:13 AM
Thread Name: singing as we would speak
Subject: RE: singing as we would speak
I remember reading somewhere that songs sung in English tend to have one note per syllable, and one syllable per word, and that that's how you tell when a song was composed in English.

Alas(1w,2s) my love(1s,2n) you do me wrong(1s,2n)
To cast me off(1s,2n) discourteously(1w,5s,4n)

So what language was Greensleeves composed in?

The way I sing it, the two syllable 'Greensleeves' has, at different points, 2, 3 and 4 notes.

There are many, many more English songs that don't conform to the 'one note per syllable, and one syllable per word' tendancy.

DC