The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #13199   Message #428781
Posted By: radriano
29-Mar-01 - 06:17 PM
Thread Name: Lyr Add: When All Men Sing (K Scowcroft, D Gifford
Subject: RE: Lyr Add: When All Men Sing
You know, as I think more about it, it does kinda make sense but you rarely, if ever, hear singing shift from harmony to unison.

I believe unison singing is found in parts of Ireland. I know that the famous Clancy Brothers sang mostly in unison. But Keith Scowcroft and Derek Gifford are English anyway. Is there traditional unison singing in England?

I've ordered a copy of Derek Gifford's recording through the Chantey Cabin website. Maybe I can get in touch with Gifford and ask him about it.

Hey, I just had a flash. It makes more sense, to me, if that fifth line in the last verse read "Now in unison pours forth the song." That would signify that the shift from harmony to unison were planned.


Richard