I almost didn't read this thread because I didn't want to get in a theoretical discussion.

Glad I read it. I really like the song & the issues aren't theoretical. I can see why some might not like it, I think this song is just a little too close for comfort. It's not what it you're saying about Jesus or his folks that's the problem. It's when we find ourselves in the attitudes of the neighbors, that hurts. We can excuse the men of the song, in a pre-resurrection context, but have no excuse for ourselves.

Just a niggle, shouldn't it be The First Holy Saturday? It sounds like the day after the crucifixion, but before the resurrection. Good Friday has a more familiar, meaningful ring, though. Probably better marketing. :-)