The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #33567   Message #448763
Posted By: Sandy Paton
25-Apr-01 - 02:11 AM
Thread Name: Origins: The Cruel Brother (Child #11)
Subject: RE: 'thecruelbrother'lyrics
Joe, you've earned the right to make wise cracks anytime! Thanks again, lad!

It occurs to me that I ought to point out that the verse I quoted above as one I choose to sing rather than the one originally collected with the ballad, namely:

Carry me to yonders stile
And lay me down while I bleed awhile.

was modified slightly from another Appalachian version, collected in 1939 by Herbert Halpert from Mrs. Polly Johnson in Wise, Virginia. I didn't make it up myself.

Sandy