I came up a Baptist and I don't think I have ever had kreplach.... I believe I would like it though! I have had that sweet pastry thing that starts with an r that I don't know how to spell. Rugelach? Dunno.
My supervisor is Jewish and back in December I asked her if she made potato latkes for Hannukah. Sure, she said, why don't you and Paul come for supper? So we did. I had my first-ever potato latke at the age of 33. We had a great time. :-)