It's not pedantics Peg. You might as well ask, why do these arguments always devolve into somebody trying to impose logic on the discussion. A discussion is a sharing of ideas if its just all of us hooraying with each other over slogans and quips, it would be called a pep rally. Also, I am not picking apart Kendall's opinion...I was pointing out that although I respect his opinion, the article he chose to post neither supported nor refuted his opinion...in fact it is totally irrelevant to any opinion since it doesn't really say anything.