The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #38045   Message #534832
Posted By: Sorcha
24-Aug-01 - 07:29 PM
Thread Name: To Tune or Not to Tune
Subject: RE: To Tune or Not to Tune
TUNE IT OR DIE!!

There are several problems for me with alternate tunings.
1) For every tuning, you have to learn new fingering.
2) It takes time to re-tune. Are you going to "patter" when folks came to hear you play or are you going to own a LOT of different instruments?
3) Alt. tuning often puts the tune/song in a different key from what it "says" it is. Can you figure out what key it actually is in to notify your fellow players?

Consequently, (with fiddle) I never use alt. tunings even tho they are out there. I just stick with standard. If the fingering is impossible in standard tuning, I just don't do the tune.