The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #38045 Message #534904
Posted By: John Hardly
24-Aug-01 - 10:12 PM
Thread Name: To Tune or Not to Tune
Subject: RE: To Tune or Not to Tune
If I might presume to answer #3 (and apologize in advance if I get it wrong)
Alternate tunings don't change the KEY....but what they often do is set a different set of default embellishments that make playing along with someone a chore if you play with more standard embellishments.
If you play "Red Haired Boy" in DADGAD your key of D has a natural default (sus 4?)that clashes with the embellishments one usually associates with the tune in its more widely accepted Key of A......EVEN IF you are capoed up to "A" pitch.