This is bushwa. It is easy t say "Why not" because we all carry various othe rkinds voluntarily. That's a choice we make, and we choose to be the kind of person who carries IDs,credit cards, and so on.

But if we chose not to be that kind of person, the law should have no place from which to require us to. This is an erosion of personal choice and liberty.

And the "necessity" of state security is not a counter-argument of merit. Necessity has been used to justify every encroachment on civil freedoms since before the Revolution.

There is no necessity for people to be forced into ways of living they do not wish to adapt.

A