George:

Eddy seemed the most likely candidate - apart from the deep voice! Could well have been Tom Munelly, whom Terry Moylan claims wrote the song (see earleir in the thread). You might let me hear the tape sometime.

Regards

p.s. I think Dan "reconstructed" his version from what he could remember of Shay's. The story of the coincidence in Inishowen is perfectly true, by the way.