I've actually changed my opinion somewhat as a result of this thread.

When I think back on music education when I went to school (the "olden days"??!!) I have to admit that things are much, much better today. Back then, very few kids were in band, no one wanted to be in band except those already taking private lessons (very few), and the band and choral club were extra-curricular activities that met once a week and were mutually exclusive. And the band played only marches at assemblies.

That's not the case today in my son's school. He has classes for band, orchestra, jazz ensemble, concert choir, ensemble singing group and musicianship available to him. This is truly remarkable compared to what I had. So I feel bad for trashing the school system for minor points. (I guess it's never enough to a music maniac. . .)

Anyhow, the schools are doing a much better job than ever before, and some teachers are doing an outstanding job. And the variety of music played in today's bands is much better than the marches-only mentality of the past, even if it isn't to my taste.