"None of this really applies to solo guitarists. If the guitarist is good enough, the music speaks for itself, if not, then all the showmanship in the world won't compensate" --Murray MacLeod

Far be it from me to be contrary *wink wink* ...I've seen Two excellent guitarists who show that this contrast still holds up -- even when the music should "speak for itself"

Pat Donohue in concert is an excellent showman, excellent musician. El McMeen is an excellent musician and a wonderful gentleman with an easy stage presence -- but not a showman. I believe that El appeals to other guitarists but Pat appeals to guitarists and non alike.

I certainly won't argue that all the showmanship in the world won't compensate (completely) for poor musicianship -- just that excellent musicianship without good showmanship will leave an audience cold -- even with solo guitar.

Another excellent musician/showman? Catfish Keith!