I agree that its needed (and probably past time), but I also agree that there HAS to be some easy way for "strangers" to ask questions. Except for the mythological "inner core", I'd guess that most of us originally came to Mudcat that way, and the rapid and helpful response of a member (or of many members) is what made us stay. Also, if technologically possible, could the DigiTrad stay outside of the closed section? I have a number of friends who go there regularly for songs, but have no particular interest in participating in any of the discussions.