*Grin* Hey Clinton, I don't mind arguing with you a little bit from time to time, but it looks like your argument from the second paragraph on in your 12-Feb-02 - 11:08 PM post is with John P, and not with me.

However, I think I can address this one...

Look how uptight this place gets Members vs Guests when it's just about registration... can you imagine how wide the split would be if Mudcat also had a Members Only section???

I think we may be beyond issues of uptightness and into the realm of whether or not the Mudcat can survive as an entity. I guess a members only Mudcat could possibly be better than no Mudcat at all. At least from my perspective. I guess I can't really know for sure unless it actually happens. But that's what I think at this time at any rate.