The Greig-Duncan Collection was edited by Patrick Shuldrum-Shaw and Emily Lyle. They don't come any better than Emily Lyle. They quoted from The Aberdeen Journal of Wednesday, March 18, 1812: "The fine new Ship, Diamond, Gibbon, sailed on Thursday last, for the Davis' Straits Whale Fishery.", but cited no published account of the shipwreck, although they note the crew were all saved.