I remember an illegal who lived near us when I was in San Antonio (1950s). His children were born in San Antonio. They now have children of their own. Should these grandparents be shipped back south of the border? There are many thousands like him (I know, there was a so-called amnesty, but the percentage who applied- or could apply- was not very large). A new amnesty is needed now; there should be one every 20 years. The sole criterion should be gainful employment in the family.