I cant argue with Kirkpatrick or Cutting, I like the idea of Carr- all those jazz chords, but what about Richard Thomson on guitar, I dont know about Macca on bass, but maybe he'd bring along George Martin to do the arrangements. I'll plump for Liam O'Flynn on pipes, although my mate Bob is taken with Pauline Cato , I don't think Northumbrian pipes are a patch on Uillean for expression. We'll have Andy Irvine in there on bouzouki. Rick Wakeman on keyboards, maybe even Eno?? for a bit of intellectual retro glam, -talking of which Kathrine Lock on cello. I think I might start a new thread on who I wouldnt want in a band see previous thread on worst live performances.