Dear Bob, I am sort of maintaining a watch on this -- I also have a stack of e-mails -- and at some point I intend to post the (interim?) results. Your categories are pretty good. I have been fiddlng away with overdone and half-baked (for the PC songs). A real problem is drawing a line so that bad pop songs are excluded. They crop up a lot on lists. We have been this way before....Also, given the nature of the contributors, there is a North American folkie/Celtic pub divide (If I can simplify drastically) that needs to be reflected in the final listings. Fun, though. Yours, Peter