I refuse to participate in any attempt to discourage singing in public, no matter how 'off-key'. Everyone, together now, 'Lift up your voice and sing'. You can do it! The more you do it the better it will be. People who criticize you are to be ignored, and pitied. Let them sing the louder to hide thier embarrasment for your 'lack of decorum', if they are that concerned. Kendall, no criticism of you personally intended, I don't know you, but I am of the school that believes everyone can sing, if they are not ruined for it when young by 'well-meaning' people who tell them 'You sing off'key' or 'you can't carry a tune in a bucket'. What harm can there possibly be in people not hitting every note the way you think they should? Public, communal singing is one of the best ways to build community and overcome barriers. It used to be done often, and I hope that day returns. Sing Out! doesn't say anywhere in it's pages that it is only for those who have passed some kind of litmus test for vocal ability. It is for everyone, as are all songs to be sung.