Bobert, here are your lyrics with line breaks added, just in case that makes it easier for the songsmiths to compose the second verse.  (I haven't read the ones submitted so far, because I may try to write one and I don't want to be influenced by them.)

First verse:

Well, I walked down to the preacher's house,
Knockin' on the man's front door,
Said, "Preacher, can ya tell me... what'd Jesus die for?"
He said "Why, son, he died for your salvation
Up there on Calvary Hill."
I said, "Thank you there, good Reverend."
He said, "Son, it was God's will.
It was just God's will."

(Insert second verse)

 Last verse:

I say to you in sheep's clothing
That your debts will all be paid
When you try your lines on St. Peter,
Standin' at the Pearly Gates.
For Mathew said, "Nothin's hidden that one day won't be found."
Yeah, no secret's kept behind closed doors
That won't one day be known around.
You'll be known by your deeds in time,
Lives you've taken so very still,
And you'll find your empty words won't change
Your final judgment; that's God's will.
That's God's will.

Genie