The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #50817   Message #771766
Posted By: DMcG
26-Aug-02 - 12:17 PM
Thread Name: PEL and the Law: 'Twas ever thus
Subject: PEL and the Law: 'Twas ever thus
I was reading A Williams "Folk Songs of the Upper Thames" published in 1923 and came across the following paragraph:

[Why folksongs are declining - migrations etc then] At the same time, the singing of the old songs went on as long as the fairs and harvest-homes were held, and even after they were discontinued, till they began to be rigidly discountenance, or altogether forbidden at the inns. This was the most unkind and fatal repulse of all. It was chiefly brought about, I am told, not by any desire of the landlord, but by the harsh and strict supervision of the police. They practically forbade singing. The houses at which it was held i.e. those at which the poor labourers commonly gathered, were markes as disorderly places; the police looked on song-singing as a species of rowdyism. Their frequent complaints and threats to the landlords filled them with misgivings; the result was that they were forced, as a means of self-protection, to request their customers not to sing on the premises, or, at any rate, not to be allow themselves to be heard.

Sound familiar?