BWL - I thought the bite sized Sugar Daddys were called Sugar Babies.
Anyway, how about Sky Bars. A chocolate bar divided into sections with different cream fillings in each section. They still exist, but they're hard to find. I also liked Zero bars - white chocolate around nougat. Turkish Taffy, too.

If you have a Cracker Barrel restaurant near you (you have to be near an interstate) their gift shops carry hard-to-find candy like the Sky Bars, BlackJack gum, etc. They're also about the only place up north where you can get GooGoo Clusters, which is candy the way God intended it to be, except the peanut butter version isn't that good.

I almost forgot - Zagnut - a Clark Bar with coconut instead of the chocolate coating.