Just for the record, I wasn't annoyed by Bob's post, just confused as to his meaning and intention. I didn't know whether he wanted to start a debate on what a "true musician" (which seems to have happened anyway), or whether he was asking something more specific - the nub of which I couldn't ascertain from his post. I wasn't trying to nitpick or bully, just trying to find out what he wanted to know and point out the ambiguity of his post and the assumptions he was making.

Bagpuss