The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #52591   Message #806208
Posted By: Malcolm Douglas
18-Oct-02 - 01:27 PM
Thread Name: Tune Req: Rose of Allandale
Subject: RE: Rose of Allandale
No, I'm not saying that 3/4 is an improvement. The mixed rhythm that the Coppers use, however, I do consider notably superior to the original. The modern tendency to turn the song (as modified by the Coppers; I've never heard a recording or performance that was not based on their version) into a 3/4 "Country and Irish" style waltz is, to my mind, a retrograde step.