sharyn,
My personal preference is for the "real thing" (Ritchie, Riddle, Adams, Gladden, etc.)
But check out
"Custer LaRue Sings The Dæmon Lover With the Baltimore Consort, Traditional Ballads & Songs of England, Scotland & America", Dorian Recordings (DOR-90174)
Custer has the pipes and the pedigree and the arrangements will knock your socks off.