Mudlark, Homeless, have you heard the whole explanation of the two levels the story is working on? I'm wondering if that would help.

Level 1: Adventure story - Gang of people, varying races, goes out to accomplish the impossible while facing improbable odds.

Level 2: Tragedy of Loss and Endings - No matter what happens the world as it was known by the characters is going to change. And the main character (Frodo) loses everything including any chance at happiness.

But then there are always those who just aren't turned on by this kind of thing.

But I am and I can't wait to see this film! I'll see it this weekend and then again on January 4 with my kids and some friends. We will have an LOTR day, by watching the extended version of the Fellowship and then going to see TTT in the theater.