The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #54918 Message #852101
Posted By: Dave the Gnome
22-Dec-02 - 06:29 AM
Thread Name: BS: A Celtic Christmas?
Subject: BS: A Celtic Christmas?
In Woolies yesterday I decided to update our Christmas song collection with a wonderful CD containing all the classics. You know, Wizzard, Slade, Mud and Chas and Daves fantastic version of Auld Lang Syne! Anyhow, the CD's were on offer - 2 for a tenner so I mooched round a bit and found one called 'A Celtic Christmas'.
It is an excelent compilation of both vocal and musical numbers featuring whistles, harps, hooligan pipes etc. But here is the question. Why is it a CELTIC christmas? Here is the track list -
The Christ hilds lullaby Guadette The first Noel Jesum Dominum The Angel Gabriel Away in a manger Puer Nobis Veni Emmanuel Nova Infant Holy The seven joys of Mary A virgin so pure What is this fragrance? Il est ne Silent night Divinum mysterium Go to sleep my child Look, a star shines Our blessed lady's lullaby Coventry Carol Rocking Quem pastores
Don't get me wrong here. I'm not knocking anything. I genuinely do not know how many of these songs are 'Celtic'. Or is it just that they are done in the Celtic (predominantly Irish in this case) style? If so, how come? Do the Celts not have enough of their own music? Or were all these songs originaly Celtic and have crossed to other areas?
Not that it realy matters anyway - as I say it is a lovely album - and a perfect foil to the other louder braher one I got. I am just interested.