Wow! I didn't think I would stir up such a response by bringing back this thread of only 7 posts. I don't have anything against RUS, just the way it is used or misused. I have a copy, which I refer to less and less, but I don't bring it to the circle nor do I use anyone else's copy there. If I don't know the song, I find it easier to learn by careful listening rather than plowing through the words with no regard to meaning or how the words might fit with the music. Of course that is hard when many other people are plowing through.

As an instrumentalist, as well as a singer, at instrumental sessions I also think it is not good to use a book. Tunes are better learned by ear than by notes. Yes, I do admit to using notes at home, but am trying to wean myself of that approach. And at a session, if I don't know the tune I don't try to play and muddle up the music for others. Again, attentive listening is the best way to learn. Later, when I begin to pick up the tune, I quietly try to play along without disturbing others.

Sessions, both singing and instrumental, can be enjoyable and also good learning experiences. Good musicians can (and should) help those who are not as good, but sessions are their best if they result in better music. I have little patience for those who come to sessions with no thought of learning the music or becoming better musicians. The question then is why are they there?

I think I'd better stop here, and run for cover!

Cheers, S. in Seattle