If I read a book and retell the story, have I violated copyright laws? I don't think so, and I think the same should apply to singing songs. Of course if I "re-publish" that book, I have, in my mind, violated the copyright. Similarly, if I release a CD of someone else's songs, I should pay the royalties.

Richard Bridge's point that creative talents should be able to earn a living is a good one. Unfortunately, there are some in Richard's profession who are way to focused on their own monetary gain by helping society interpret the law. They have given attorney's a bad name resulting in characterizations such as:

A drunk stands up in a bar and yells, "All lawyers are assholes."
Another guy stands up and yells, "Hey, I resent that."
The drunk says, "Why? Are you a lawyer?"
The guy replies, "No, I'm an asshole."

I have been through too many horrible US Justice Department proceedings to not laugh a jokes like this.

DW