I think we are in danger of forgetting the number we first thought of.

Joe's responds to us complaining about noise from others, by using his personal judgement and placing us where he decides and this encourages yet more complaints from both sides. And this is supported by some but not by others.

In the meantime Jeff has segregated the noisy from the not so noisy, with no fuss and little pain, making Joe's contentious judgement unnecessary and one would think, making us all happy?

But no, we still MUST have it, even though the 'non wranglers' are seated together and out of sight of the original complainers?
Why? Because we just have gotten used to complaining and having the management jump to, with a heavy-hand?

Perhaps those who still must constantly complain about what other users are doing can find somewhere else to eat? Or the next thing is that they will be demanding to have to have 'bouncers' on the door, preventing the noisy from even entering.

Jeff has made all this unnecesaary, let's please just calm down give this light management touch, a chance to work, before we resort to the 'bouncers'?