Reading this thread, I have come to realize that there are so many factors involved in selecting a flute that you should not surprise your daughter with a flute you have purchased. Rather, tell her about the gift you want to make and let her choose her own by trying them out.

Wilfried Schaum: hello from another recorder player. I play soprano, alto, tenor and sopranino. I agree with you - if you want a woodwind sound,a recorder is more authentic to the Renaissance than a transverse flute. I think it also easier to play and to pack.