The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #59165   Message #942135
Posted By: Amos
28-Apr-03 - 04:11 PM
Thread Name: BS: What is Anti-Semitism?
Subject: RE: BS: What is Anti-Semitism?
DG:

Obviously you are mixing with the wrong crowd. Anyone who would jump to a racism stance when an individual person -- regardless of their faith was being criticized in a constructive, or intelligent, or specific way -- not an ad hominem way -- is obviosuly an arm-waving loony given to broad generalizations and incapable of clear precise thought.

Either that or the "criticisms" were actually personal, or wide meaningless generalizations like the one you posted above ("Yet if you criticize a Jew, it is sometimes made out to be 'racism'. The opening link may have been a lousy one to use in starting this thread in order to get to this point, but yes, that is my fundamental problem with the 'anti-semitism' tag. If you criticize someone of the Jewish religious group, you are a racist"). May I suggest you find a more discrominating group of associates to talk to, and strive mightily to be worthy of their company?

A