THANK YOU!!! wolfgang, so sorry to re-iterate a topic so old-hat...i'm still getting used to how mudcat works. forgive me. i know you guys like people to abide by the rules and keep things interesting. nevertheless, this was a great help to me, especially as i've not yet encountered a vrsion of this ballad in which the keeper of the pig is a "witch-woman"...if that ain't a goddess symbol i don't know what is. yay. if anyone knows any history on "bob porter" that would also be lovely.