I seem to have missed this thread when it was resurrected a few months ago. I ought just to mention that, just because a song has a title vaguely similar to another, it doesn't necessarily follow they are related. I'm not convinced that any of the broadsides "Storyteller" cites are related to the song under discussion here; though many contain verses in common with the last three in the set quoted some six years ago at the beginning of this thread; which, as Martin Ryan pointed out at the time, belong properly to a different song.