arrangement for General Taylor
(origins) Origins: General Taylor - who was he? (60)
Tune Req: General Taylor (6)
Beating General Taylor's Long Dead Horse (2)
Subject: arrangement for General Taylor|
From: GUEST,Riaz Mohammed
Date: 25 Aug 10 - 11:38 PM
I'd like to have the men's section of my choir sing the Great Big Sea arrangement for "General Taylor".
I'm having some trouble finding it as GBS does not have one available and I have not had any luck using a Google search.
Subject: RE: arrangement for General Taylor|
From: Joe Offer
Date: 26 Aug 10 - 01:13 AM
That's an interesting question, Mohammed. I don't know that I'd want to do the Great Big Sea arrangement myself. The chanteyman part is very distinctive, and suited only to that one particular singer, I think. Better to get a talented chanteyman who can listen to a number of different versions and then develop his own.
I can see where there might be an advantage for a chorus to have an arrangement for the responses, although I prefer to make up my own bass part as I go along.
What I would suggest is that you might want to ask if a Mudcatter would like to work with you to develop an arrangement that would work with your choir. I think that's something we should be doing more often here. I'd volunteer, but that's beyond my capabilities. But we do have some very good arrangers here.
I'm listening to various recordings of "General Taylor" on Spotify right now. It's amazing how wide the variety is. The version playing now is from Fairport Convention, with a band - it's very distinctive.