Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: JedMarum Date: 31 May 01 - 04:02 PM Peter - there may be others who have interest in reading this info, so I'll respond on the forum. I actually use an open D major tuning that is based upon a Nashville tuning; ie. the bottom four strings are an octave higher then the standard tuning. This creates an odd octave break between the 3rd and the 2nd string. It also creates a very pretty combination of high notes on the botton, with drone strings on top. There is a more detailed article about this tuning here, but I am now doing this with a full sized guitar too. Anyway - this tuning adds to beauty of this haunting melody. I do use a slight variation of the melodies linked in the DT ... I will make a tape and send it to you, if you provide me with your mailing addr via PM. To play the song, I finger pick and brush playing the melody a bit while I sing ... I use a chord that looks like the standard E7 and slide it up the neck to make the run from the root to the 4 chord, then use a minor based chord (with drones) and the 5 chrod. I could actually do a chart for this pretty easily. Then I'll post it. It should be done today. I'll be back with a link! |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Peter T. Date: 31 May 01 - 01:49 PM Jed, How do you do your version? (if you wanted to send me a Personal Message, that would be nice, or you can roll along here, depending on the alligators). I have been working on it in open D for awhile, and cannot get the hang of it. The chord structure seems so wayward, and the changes are so fast. Where do you place the chords, or do you do the melody, or how? I would be very grateful for any advice. I have been stuck on it. yours, Peter T. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: JedMarum Date: 31 May 01 - 11:48 AM so what did we decide? why is his moeny no good? I sing a variation of this version and use a DADF#AD tuning (D major). The story in all the versions I've seen seem to report a real experience of an almost romance - I find it hard to believe the original version was not written by someone who had this experience. The other circumstances change a bit. It seems possible it's a story from just after the US Civil War; my money's no good, and I curse all foreign money - a Confederate soldier would have felt the US currency to be foreign, perhaps, but he also would have found his confederate currency worthless for some time, even if he had any - and it is likely that following the CW he would have need of renewing his fortune. I am just convinced the song describes this era accurately. BUT, the main issue of the song, of course is the relationship ... so what matter when ... or even where? Any more thoughts on the song? |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: McGrath of Harlow Date: 03 Jun 00 - 04:15 PM They had this programme about Croc hunting in Australia the other night on our telly. Strewth, you wouldn't catch me sleeping out in the woods if any of them fellas were about... |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Murray MacLeod Date: 03 Jun 00 - 03:32 PM Informative contribution, Ship'scat. So now I can be certain that "alligators " is not a corruption of "Alleghenians " ? Murray |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Ship'scat Date: 03 Jun 00 - 11:43 AM With applogies to Joe and all but us amateur navigators have buttons too:
Ponchartrain Lakes are five miles north of New Orleans in the state of Louisiana.
Actually Lake Pontchartrain is on the border of the city of New Orleans and Orleans Parish (our equivilent of county). 5 Miles north of New Orleans is in the middle of the lake which itself is 24 miles wide at the Causeway connecting the South shore (New Orleans) with the North shore (Mandeville, Covington, Folsom, etc)
New Orleans is bounded by the Mississippi River on its South (and East and West which is why we are called the Crescent City) and by Lake Pontchartrain on its North. Locals don't use points of the compass but "river-side" and "lake-side" to communicate directions.
The distance between the Lake and the River is 4.98 miles at its narrowest and 8.03 at its widest. (Its 4.17 between river and lake in the suburb of Metairie)
These lakes are a constant menace to New Orleans, their waters having to be kept away by great earthen dykes.
The great earthen dykes are called levies As an aside, New Orleans is bounded on the East and West by aligator-infested wetlands (swamps). The gators stocked are harvested on an annual cycle with the proportion males to females carefully controlled by incubating the gathered eggs. So much for romance! |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: McGrath of Harlow Date: 02 Jun 00 - 01:56 PM Singing it to the tune of The Sash? Now that could be fun. It's a great tune after all.
|
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Axeman Date: 01 Jun 00 - 11:29 PM I'm indebted for all the citings! All hail to Paul Brady, and especially to his latest version on "Nobody Knows" which I find electrifying. I loved looking at the big Lake flying N. away from the Big Easy! As I recall, Nanci Griffith does a bnice version too. -Axe' |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,John of the Hill Date: 01 Jun 00 - 10:19 PM Art, Maybe it should be pointed out that it is kay-ro or care-o, anything but kie-ro. Thanks for posting that version, I'll have to sing it around the campfire at the Stringbender Festival at Cairo this fall. John |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: raredance Date: 01 Jun 00 - 10:06 PM I found an abbreviated version of LOP in "Folk songs Out of Wisconsin" by Harry Peters. The notes say that it was sung by Mrs. Fances Perry of Black River Falls in 1946. Mrs. Perry said that the song came from the mountain people of Georgia. The tune included is not the usual one and sounds sort of familiar to me, but I am unable to place it. The claim of a Georgia origin is interesting since most of the collected versions seem to come from up north. rich r |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 01 Jun 00 - 05:22 PM Nice one, Martin. I particularly liked his oblique reference to Dr. Oliver Sacks' book on Aphasiacs - "The man who mistook his wife for a hat" B. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 01 Jun 00 - 05:00 PM There's a few of them, all right. I use the melody Paul uses, but one of the other melodies is on the tip of me tounge, so to speak. B. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: MartinRyan Date: 01 Jun 00 - 05:00 PM In fact THIS interesting article makes the same link. Regards |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: MartinRyan Date: 01 Jun 00 - 04:52 PM What tunes do we have for this - apart from the one Paul Brady uses? I heard a guy singing it to Irish Molly/The Sash the other day. I know I've heard it used before but am damned if I remember who or when. Regards p.s. Helen Creighton was the oldest reference I remember coming across. Must have another look. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 09 May 00 - 06:25 PM The definitive version in any context means the version that defines the song; the benchmark by which all else is judged; Of recognized authority or excellence, perhaps. Authoritative, classical, determinate, unequivocal. Then of course we could have, conclusive, explicit, expressed, standard. Or to be more obtuse "Pick the bones out of that one!" Incidentally, have you listened to Paul's version on 'Your welcome here kind stranger'? You'll know what is meant then.*BG* B. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: IanC Date: 09 May 00 - 07:55 AM I've been looking at the broadside ballads in the Bodleian Library collection. There are a number of copies of a C19th ballad called "The Indian Lass" which appears to have quite a few features in common with the Banks of Pontchartrain song, including the approxiamte location. The slant is slightly different, but it has the element of the stranger made welcome. By the way, Planxty do my favourite version. What does definitive mean in this context? |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,Arkie Date: 09 May 00 - 12:18 AM Isn't this song also sometimes known as "The Creole Girl"? |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 08 May 00 - 10:43 PM Good man P.J. I hope you don't mind if I put the links in. 2: RTÉ Online It is good to know where you are these days. B. |
Subject: Lyr Add: LAKES OF PONCHARTRAIN (Illinois version) From: Art Thieme Date: 08 May 00 - 06:16 PM This is "definitely" from Illinois !?
It was on the 3rd of January I bid Cairo town adieu,
I swung on board of an old boxcar just as the day did dawn, Art Thieme |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Kim C Date: 08 May 00 - 04:38 PM It may be we haven't come across a definitive answer simply because there isn't one. I don't like that either, but sometimes that's what happens when you try to date a song ----- the dates just aren't available for whatever reason. Just because a song was collected in 1898 or 1922 or whatever doesn't mean it wasn't around LONG before then. Songs can get passed around bookoos of times before they're ever seen in print. If you were to say that it has its origins -sometime- in the 19th century, you would probably be quite correct. ------------ KFC |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: IanC Date: 08 May 00 - 05:23 AM Joe We seem to be getting there quite fast. Don't forget folk music isn't an exact science. If you're looking to pin down an origin, though, it's often useful to find a logical earliest date as well as a latest date (as we are doing so far). Any offers on when the items in the song could have been first assembled (creole girls, pontchartrain etc.) ?? Cheers! IanC |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: DADGBE Date: 07 May 00 - 07:26 PM Hi Frankie, A pleasure! Check out the book for the melody, it's pure cowboy through and through. Hi Joe, If I ever get free of friday night gigs, Jane and I'd love to come and sing! Although the world knows me as DADGBE, my close friends call me herr professor doktor DADGBE. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,Frankie Date: 07 May 00 - 08:44 AM BTW, Paul Brady recorded Ponchartrain (as well as Arhtur McBride) again for his Nobody Knows collection which mostly contains his original Rock/Pop numbers. To my ears the newer version is even better than the original on Welcome Here Kind Stranger, if that's possible. Drop D, thanks for the very cool cowboy version. Frankie |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,PJ Curtis. Date: 07 May 00 - 05:00 AM Brendan, Nowhere to run ....nowhere to hide!!. Nice to meet you in Mudcat land. Ill pass your regards to our mutual friend. Yes, I do a worldmusic/roots/trad. prog . on LyricFm 'Reels To Ragas' wed 7-8pm (www.lyricfm.ie). also a prog. called Rhythm & Roos on Radio 1 Sun 8-9pm (www.rte.ie) I must get around to playing Paul Brady's version of The lakes of Ponchartrain soon. best wishes from all in Co. Clare, PJc |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 07 May 00 - 01:44 AM Sorry. I put a link in that didn't work. This one shouldP.J. Curtis BTW If you see Austin Durack - tell him I said hello. B. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Brendy Date: 07 May 00 - 01:40 AM Whatever about whatever and whosever version is the best, Paul Brady's is the definitive version and all subsequent versions have been in one way or another influenced by it. Good on you P.J. I always loved your shows on Clare FM and listened religiously to them. I was going to provide a link there, but I see you have moved to Fair play to you, my man. It's good to see you here. Brendan McKeever |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: raredance Date: 06 May 00 - 02:38 PM Well Joe, it seems clear the 1924 early date of publication from the Traditional Ballad Index is not correct. A text version of it was collected in Ohio and published by Tolman in the Journal of American Folklore Vol 35, which was 1922. this is cited by both Laws and Randolph. Randaolph also says it can be foun in Americn Ballads and Songs by Louise Pound also published in 1922. Randolph's collection was in 1924 from a Mrs Carrie Baber of Pinville, MO. Mrs. Baber stated that she learned the song about 1898 and that she always wondered about the title. She said, "It don't seem to make sense, but that's what it is..." The reason being is that her version had the line "From the banks of the Ponsaw Train". So either she corrupted it or her source in the late 1890's had it messed up. If an incorrect version dates from 1898, then you might argue that the correct version predates that. Both Randolph and Laws also mention a version by Stout in "Folkore From Iowa" where the stanzas end witrh the line "on the Lakes Upon". Stout's work was published in 1936. A version is also found in "The New Green Mountain Songster" by Flanders and Barry (1939). They put forth the proposition that LOP is a companion piece to "The Little Mohea". IN Mohea, the man declines the marriage proposal because he has a girl at home. In LOP it is reversed, the girl refuses the proposal because of a lover away. They state "It is very probable that the author knew and imitated 'The Little Mohea'". Flanders and Barry also claim that theirs is the first pinted version with music. They obviously did not have a copy of Creighton's Ballads and Songs of Nova Scotia. The two tunes, however, are not the same. Time to go back out and do some more gardening rich r
|
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Jon Freeman Date: 05 May 00 - 09:38 PM If I remember right, there was a thread on this song and a possible relationship to Flora the Lily of the West in rec.music.folk last year. Maybe worth a look in deja news but all I seem to remember is the same tune being used to by somebody. Jon |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Mbo Date: 05 May 00 - 09:31 PM No no, Andy M. Stewart's version is THE best, with Gerry O'Beirne playing dobro along with him. Goosebumps! --Mbo |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Joe Offer Date: 05 May 00 - 09:26 PM OK, I don't want to be a wet blanket around here or anything, but here we have scholars as esteemed as Charlie Baum and The Artist Known Only By His Guitar Tuning (DADGBE), and we still don't have a solid answer to the original question. It seems like this is a song that everybody has known forever, but yet we can't find mention of it before Sam Henry's contention that it was heard in Ireland in 1905. Helen Creighton put in in Songs and Ballads from Nova Scotia (1932), but doesn't give a date for it. I believe the tune is often also used for Peter Emberley, isn't it? So, allow me to repeat the original question - when and where does this song come from? I've been tempted to do this at our Wednesday night sing, but I'd much rather have DADGBE grace us with his presence and sing his Los Angeles version for us. How 'bout it, Ray? -Joe Offer in Sacramento- |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Jon W. Date: 05 May 00 - 05:50 PM But Louisiana was pretty big in 1803 when Jefferson Purchased it and included some areas considered to be desert back then (the Great Plains). |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,Peter T. Date: 05 May 00 - 02:43 PM Makes sense to me: in Puccini's Manon Lescaut, the heroine dies of thirst in the deserts of Louisiana. yours, Peter T. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Charlie Baum Date: 05 May 00 - 02:09 PM LA is the abbreviation, not only for Los Angeles, but Louisiana as well. |
Subject: Lyr Add: ON THE LAKE OF THE PONCHO PLAINS From: DADGBE Date: 05 May 00 - 01:48 PM Hi all, There's an unusual version of "Ponchartrain" called "On The Lake Of The Poncho Plains" in Margret Larkin's 1931 book, "Singing Cowboy, A Book of Western Songs". Oak Publications reprinted it in 1963. Ms. Reva Cordell collected it from an unnamed cowboy at a rodeo in the late 1920's. ON THE LAKE OF THE PONCHO PLAINS It was late one summer's evening when I bid L.A. adieu, And started my way to Texas which I was forced to do, Through swamps of alligators I started my weary way, Over railroad ties and crossings my weary feet did play. It was getting late one evening when higher ground I gain, It was there that I met the Cree girl on the Lake of the Poncho Plains, "Good evening fair damsel. My money is no good. If it wasn't for the alligators I'd sleep out in the woods." She taken me to her mother's house and treated me quite well, Her raven hair in ringlets around her shoulders fell, I tried to paint her beauty but found it was in vain, Oh how handsome was that Cree girl on the Lake of the Poncho Plains. I begged her then to wed me, she said it ne'er could be, She said she had a lover and he was far at sea, She said she had a true lover and true she would remain, 'Till he returned to her again on the Lake of the Poncho Plains. Adieu to you my pretty miss I may never see you more, But I'll always remember your kindness that was shown by your cottage door, It's around the flaming circle, a cup to my lips I drain, Drink success to the beautiful Cree girl on the Lake of the Poncho Plains. It's a great piece of folklore where older words have gotten mixed up with newer adaptations. I mean, imagine riding east from Los Angeles through swamps of alligators!! The melody is completely changed too so you'll have to find the book or give me a shout when you're in California and I'll sing it for you.
|
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,PJ Curtis. Date: 05 May 00 - 01:06 PM What!!! Not one mention of Paul Brady's definative version. PJC. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Kim C Date: 05 May 00 - 12:15 PM It's my understanding that this song goes back at least to the War of 1812 and that the melody is older. Whether that's true or not, I don't know. I have seen several different versions of lyrics. I think it's just one of those that's so old, and has undergone so many transformations, the original composer is lost to history. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GeorgeH Date: 05 May 00 - 08:14 AM Yup, I'll go with the Martin Simpson recommendation on this . . as I recall he's sung some different arrangements of it over the years. Great to here Martin featured on the UK's Radio 3 "Late Junction" the other evening - tracks from two very contrasting CDs of his. G. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Stewie Date: 05 May 00 - 01:21 AM My favourite rendition is Martin Simpson's - with a decidedly cajun flavour which suits it admirably. --Stewie. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,Mrbisok@aol Date: 04 May 00 - 11:05 PM You got it, that's the best line, I've always loved it as I love anyone who loves what I love. Signed, happily married (and retired from 36 years of teaching) Harold from Hawthorne. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Malcolm Douglas Date: 04 May 00 - 10:22 PM There are 4 versions on the DT, here, here, here, and here. Also worth looking at this thread: The Lakes of Ponchartrain. A search through the new "Digitrad and Forum Search" box on the Forum page for "Lakes of Ponchartrain" and "Lily of the West" will also get you lots of additional information. Malcolm |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Murray MacLeod Date: 04 May 00 - 10:21 PM "Lakes of Pontchartrain" is one of my all time favourites too, especially the "alligator" version, as sung by Paul Brady. The first time I ever heard the song was listening to Paul Brady's set at Cambridge Folk Festival in 1975. I was told some years ago that the "alligators" in this line is actually a corruption of "Alleghenians", presumably referring to a tribe of Indians. However even my sketchy knowledge of American geography tells me that the Alleghenian mountains are nowhere near Lake Pontchartrain, so this may have been misleading information. Murray |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: alison Date: 04 May 00 - 10:15 PM Heard Andy M Stewart singing this earlier this year.. he claimed it was an American civil war song..... about a soldier who found himself on the wrong side of enemy lines, with the wrong currency hence "my money it is no good".... The Christy Moore Songbook says "I learned this song in 1966 from the singing of Mike Waterson of Hull. Ponchartrain is situated outside New Orleans and is reputed to be an American Civil war song about a soldier who found himself on the wrong side of the line after the truce and was helped out of his predicament by a woman." so there's 2 opinions for you...
slainte alison |
Subject: Origins: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Joe Offer Date: 04 May 00 - 09:56 PM Hi - the information in the Traditional Ballad Index (click) on this song isn't satisfying, but it's a start. I'm not sure about that date, 1924, that they have listed - I think it's the earliest date they found it in print. Here's what I found in Sam Henry's Songs of the People: The Lakes of Ponchartrain -Joe Offer- Lake of Ponchartrain, The [Laws H9]DESCRIPTION: A young man (Union soldier?), lost in the south, is taken in by a Creole girl. He asks her to marry; she cannot, for she is promised to another who is far away (at sea?). He promises to remember her alwaysAUTHOR: unknown EARLIEST DATE: 1922 (Pound) KEYWORDS: courting separation promise FOUND IN: US(Ap,MW,NE,So) Ireland Canada(Mar,Ont,West) REFERENCES (14 citations): Laws H9, "The Lake of Ponchartrain" Flanders/Ballard/Brown/Barry-NewGreenMountainSongster, pp. 147-148, "The Lake of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Huntington-FolksongsFromMarthasVineyard, pp. 48-49, "The Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Randolph 882, "The Ponsaw Train" (1 text, 1 tune) Larkin-SingingCowboy, pp. 46-48, "On the Lake of the Poncho Plains" (1 text, 1 tune) Peters-FolkSongsOutOfWisconsin, p. 134, "On the Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Pound-AmericanBalladsAndSongs, 55, pp. 127-128, "The Creole Girl" (1 text) Gardner/Chickering-BalladsAndSongsOfSouthernMichigan 45, "The Lake of Ponchartrain" (1 text plus mention of 1 more) Stout-FolkloreFromIowa 67, pp. 90-91, "The Creole GIrl" (1 text) Creighton-SongsAndBalladsFromNovaScotia 137, "On the Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Manny/Wilson-SongsOfMiramichi 78, "The Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Henry/Huntingdon/Herrmann-SamHenrysSongsOfThePeople H619, pp. 373-374, "The Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text, 1 tune) Cohen-AmericanFolkSongsARegionalEncyclopedia1, pp. 342, "The Lakes of Ponchartrain" (1 text) DT 649, PONTCHAR PONCHAR2 PONCHAR3 PONCHAR4 Roud #1836 RECORDINGS: Sarah Ann Bartley, "Lakes of Ponchartraine" (on Saskatch01) Walter Coon, "Creole Girls" (Superior 2521, 1930) Frances Perry, "On the Lakes of Ponchartrain" (AFS, 1946; on LC55) Pie Plant Pete [pseud. for Claude Moye], "The Lake of Ponchartrain" (Supertone 9717, 1930) (Perfect 5-10-14/Melotone 5-10-14, 1935; rec. 1934) Art Thieme, "The Lake of Ponchartrain" (on Thieme05) Mrs. William Towns, "Lakes of Ponsereetain" (on ONEFowke01) ALTERNATE TITLES: The Lakes of the Ponchartrain File: LH09 Go to the Ballad Search form Go to the Ballad Index Instructions The Ballad Index Copyright 2021 by Robert B. Waltz and David G. Engle. |
Subject: RE: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: Susan A-R Date: 04 May 00 - 09:54 PM Hmmm, is that the one with THE best line ever "If not for the aligators, I'd sleep out in the woods." or is it a more recent one? Susan A-R |
Subject: Lakes of Ponchartrain From: GUEST,Mrbisok@aol Date: 04 May 00 - 09:44 PM I just finished reading, again, the great lyrics to "Lakes of Ponchartrain." Who first wrote this song, lyrics and tune? Where does it come from? Is there any connection to Hank Williams' "By the banks of Ponchartrain"? This has been on my mind for l0 years, but now that I'm on the net, I can make my questions public. |
Share Thread: |
Subject: | Help |
From: | |
Preview Automatic Linebreaks Make a link ("blue clicky") |