Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Thompson Date: 18 Nov 23 - 02:33 AM My thought exactly: is this about the growing obesity problem? More seriously, is this a song sung by comfortable middle-class people (probably with great bums) or by actual hoboes? |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Lighter Date: 11 Nov 23 - 10:27 AM "Bum" isn't used for "buttocks" very much in the USA. So there's little ambiguity. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Lighter Date: 10 Nov 23 - 05:59 PM Historical fun fact: McClintock's song (12 Dec 14, from Joe) was entered (without his name) as evidence in the U.S. House of Representatives, "Investigation of Communist Propaganda: Hearings Before a Special Committee to Investigate Communist Activities in the United States" (1930). It was being promoted, along with "The Red Flag" and other songs for "workers' education," by Communist Party members in Pontiac, Michigan. In 1928 McClintock copyrighted the following titles: Big Rock Candy Mountains. In the Big Rock Candy Mountains. Hallelujah I'm a Bum. Bum's Song. Bum Song No. 2. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Mrrzy Date: 10 Nov 23 - 12:02 PM Plums? Prunes don't grow, do they? |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 13 Nov 23 - 03:19 PM A better-known song is Hallelujah, I'm a Bum. And we don't find that ambiguous, either. -Joe- |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 10 Nov 23 - 05:59 PM Mrr....the line is "packed the elusive prune." For a while, the local growers tried to market their produce as "California dried plums." That was a fiasco, and they're back to calling them prunes. And yes, if you want to be pedantic, I guess I have to say I'm from "plum picking and prune packing" country. Is that satisfactory? -Joe- |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 07 Nov 23 - 01:43 AM Hi, Jon - I come from prune picking & packing country in Central California (Yuba City is the center). Prunes are a bit difficult to pack. Like raisins, they have to be picked, then dried on cardboard trays on the ground, then packed before they get wet and moldy. A rain will ruin them. It's hard work in hot weather. So, yes, prune packing is an elusive quest. People just don't take prunes seriously, and it's a shame. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 11:47 AM "Bum" is used for "buttocks", Elsewhere in the English speaking west,so it is reasonable to say it is ambiguous, |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 10:22 AM Is not the phrase "the Grear American Bum" a little unfortunate?, since there seem to be an increasing amount of overweight obese weserners |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 01:49 AM on the subject of prunes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgVlRvl2DI0 subject of prunes |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,Jon Bartlett Date: 01 Nov 23 - 10:21 PM I'm writing a longish paper on Haywire Mac and pulling together all the bits of info I can find. I've got the Folkways recording and the British Archive of Country Songs CD etc., but I'd like to know what this line is all about: ... and packed the elusive prune I suspect it's a slang term and nothing to do with actual prunes. Any ideas out there? Jon Bartlett |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Thompson Date: 18 Nov 23 - 02:33 AM My thought exactly: is this about the growing obesity problem? More seriously, is this a song sung by comfortable middle-class people (probably with great bums) or by actual hoboes? |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 13 Nov 23 - 03:19 PM A better-known song is Hallelujah, I'm a Bum. And we don't find that ambiguous, either. -Joe- |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 11:47 AM "Bum" is used for "buttocks", Elsewhere in the English speaking west,so it is reasonable to say it is ambiguous, |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Lighter Date: 11 Nov 23 - 10:27 AM "Bum" isn't used for "buttocks" very much in the USA. So there's little ambiguity. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 10:22 AM Is not the phrase "the Grear American Bum" a little unfortunate?, since there seem to be an increasing amount of overweight obese weserners |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,RJM Date: 11 Nov 23 - 01:49 AM on the subject of prunes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgVlRvl2DI0 subject of prunes |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 10 Nov 23 - 05:59 PM Mrr....the line is "packed the elusive prune." For a while, the local growers tried to market their produce as "California dried plums." That was a fiasco, and they're back to calling them prunes. And yes, if you want to be pedantic, I guess I have to say I'm from "plum picking and prune packing" country. Is that satisfactory? -Joe- |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Lighter Date: 10 Nov 23 - 05:59 PM Historical fun fact: McClintock's song (12 Dec 14, from Joe) was entered (without his name) as evidence in the U.S. House of Representatives, "Investigation of Communist Propaganda: Hearings Before a Special Committee to Investigate Communist Activities in the United States" (1930). It was being promoted, along with "The Red Flag" and other songs for "workers' education," by Communist Party members in Pontiac, Michigan. In 1928 McClintock copyrighted the following titles: Big Rock Candy Mountains. In the Big Rock Candy Mountains. Hallelujah I'm a Bum. Bum's Song. Bum Song No. 2. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Mrrzy Date: 10 Nov 23 - 12:02 PM Plums? Prunes don't grow, do they? |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 07 Nov 23 - 01:43 AM Hi, Jon - I come from prune picking & packing country in Central California (Yuba City is the center). Prunes are a bit difficult to pack. Like raisins, they have to be picked, then dried on cardboard trays on the ground, then packed before they get wet and moldy. A rain will ruin them. It's hard work in hot weather. So, yes, prune packing is an elusive quest. People just don't take prunes seriously, and it's a shame. |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: GUEST,Jon Bartlett Date: 01 Nov 23 - 10:21 PM I'm writing a longish paper on Haywire Mac and pulling together all the bits of info I can find. I've got the Folkways recording and the British Archive of Country Songs CD etc., but I'd like to know what this line is all about: ... and packed the elusive prune I suspect it's a slang term and nothing to do with actual prunes. Any ideas out there? Jon Bartlett |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Bill D Date: 29 Apr 20 - 05:51 PM Uncle Dave O said years ago up there ^ that he had found The Bum Song on Rose, the Record Lady's site.. which is long gone. But sneaky old me downloaded those about the time Dave was posting. I went to the listing he mentioned,51ae.ra .. and LO! There was the recording by Vernon Dalhart. Rose didn't include the song title and artist in the online version, but somewhere I got most of them named and printed. I have not renamed the Real Audio files on my computer, though... and can't do a direct search. It was great to find Uncle Dave's post. Hooray for Mudcat keeping all our discussions... |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Raedwulf Date: 29 Apr 20 - 03:07 PM Gallus - Actually, my thought on seeing the title was, "Well, surely y'all know that Ma Trump & Pa Trump did That Thing and..." ;-) Therefore curiosity made me click! But cnd is right Joe - looks like there's an unclosed tag since your 17/4/12 post... and since you're the next post... Joe, you naughty little man! ;-) |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Gallus Moll Date: 29 Apr 20 - 02:49 PM OK I confess to not having read every post, but - am I the only person that feels the giggles coming on when I see a discussion about 'bums'?!!!! I realise it is a cultural thing - when my Californian pal went on about her 'fanny' or her love for 'nookie' brown ale back in the 1980s she couldn't understand why we in Scotland were howling with laughter!!!!! |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: cnd Date: 27 Apr 20 - 04:27 PM Joe, I have nothing to contribute to this thread itself, but I wanted to comment that ever since your 17 Apr 12 - 02:54 AM post the text has been larger and the margins shifted to the left some. Though normally HTML issues only live in one comment, I suspect there's some sort of way that a closed tag from that comment worked its way down into the rest of the thread. Whew! Found it. -Joe- |
Subject: RE: Origins: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 27 Apr 20 - 02:52 PM Here's the Vernon Dalhart recording: Here's the 1928 recording from Harry McClintock of "The Bum Song": And here's the Cisco Houston recording: As Mark Ross says above, Cisco Houston combines "Great American Bum" with "I Don't Wanna Be Rich," which he uses very nicely as a chorus. |
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Great American Bum From: Mark Ross Date: 13 Dec 14 - 05:55 PM Cisco paired a cut down version of THE BUM SONG with I DON'T WANNA BE RICH. I learned that version from Fred Holstein. Mark Ross |
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Great American Bum From: Mrrzy Date: 13 Dec 14 - 05:04 PM Ah, yes, Cisco Houston. I should read before I post, apparently. |
Subject: ADD: The Bum's Song (Harry McClintock) From: Joe Offer Date: 12 Dec 14 - 07:34 PM Here's my transcription of 1928 sheet music I found of "The Bum's Song," which claims words and music are by Harry McClintock http://78records.cdbpdx.com/BumSong/BumSong-s.pdf THE BUM'S SONG (Harry "Mac" McClintock) 1. Come all you jolly jokers And listen while I hum A story I'll relate to you Of the great American Bum From the East, the West, the North, the South Like a swarm of bees they come We sleep in the dirt and wear a shirt That is dirty and full of crumbs. 2. Oh it's early in the morning And the dew is off the ground The Bum arises from his nest and gazes all around From the boxcar and the hay stack He gazes everywhere He never turns back upon his track, until he gets a square. 3. I beat my way from Frisco Bay To the rock-bound coast of Maine To Canada and Mexico, Then wandered back again I've met town clowns and harness 'bulls' As tough as a cop could be And I've been in every calaboose In this Land of Liberty. 4. I've topped the spruce and worked the sluice And taken a turn at the plow I've searched for gold in the rain and cold And worked on a river scow I've dug the clam and built the dam And packed the elusive prune But my troubles fail when I hit the trail, A-paddlin' my own balloon. 5. Oh a-standin' in the railroad yard A waitin' for a train A-waitin' for a West bound freight, But think it's all in vain Going East they're loaded, Going west sealed tight I think we'll have to get aboard The fast Express tonight. 6. Oh lady would you be kind enough to give me something to eat, A piece of bread and butter And a ten foot slice of meat. A piece of pie and custard To tickle my appetite, For really I'm so hungry, I don't know where to sleep tonight. 7. Oh sleepin' against the station, Tra la la la la lation Well that's our recommedation, Hurrah Hurree Hurrum For we're three Bums, three jolly old Bums, we live like royal Turks We have good luck a-bummin' our chuck, And never bother to work. 8. I met a man the other day, I'd never met before He asked me if I wanted a job, A-shovlin' iron ore I asked him what the wages were, And he said, "Ten cents a ton" I said, "Old feller, go chase yourself, I'd rather be on the bum." 9. Oh sleepin' in the pogies, Ogie, Ogie, Ogies A-smokin' snipes and stogies, Hurrah Hurree Hurrum For we're three Bums, three jolly old Bums, we live like royal Turks We have good luck a-bummin' our chuck, God bless the man that works. Living in the Land of Prunes, I appreciate the line about the "elusive prune." Most of the U.S. prune crop is grown not far from here in Yuba City, California. The marketing people tried to rename them "California Dried Plums," but the onslaught of ridicule brought the word "Prune" back into favor. |
Subject: ADD: Shovellin' Iron Ore (from Sandburg) From: Joe Offer Date: 12 Dec 14 - 02:52 PM But there's more in Sandburg: SHOVELLIN' IRON ORE Something happened the other day, that never happened before. A man tried to get me to shovel iron ore. Says I, "Old man, now what will you pay?" Says he, "Two bits a ton." Says I, "Old man, go diddle yourself, I'd rather bum." Notes: "I got a snootful of it and I'll never go back," a fellow coal shoveler told me once in Omaha. He was speaking of iron ore, heavier, dirtier, more infiltrating than coal dust...Those who sing this usually hook it up with "We Are Four Bums." from Carl Sandburg, The American Songbag (1927), page 182 |
Subject: ADD Version: We Are Four Bums (Sandburg) From: Joe Offer Date: 12 Dec 14 - 02:46 PM Sandburg's version is just a bit longer than what Jon Bartlett posted above. WE ARE FOUR BUMS (from Sandburg) We are four bums, four jolly good chums, We live like royal Turks; We're having good luck, in bumming our chuck, God bless the man that works. We are four bums, four jolly good chums, We live like royal Turks; We're having good luck, in bumming our chuck, To hell with the man that works. from Carl Sandburg, The American Songbag (1927), page 192 Notes: If a man shall not work neither shall he eat...Is that so?...A bums' song...heard among glee club boys and among persons who go to the Barber's College for a haircut... |
Subject: ADD Versions: Great American Bum From: Joe Offer Date: 17 Apr 12 - 02:54 AM johnbob.net has four versions: A song Dad used to sing... (a BIG thank you to Cat Yronwode for sending me the words. I only ever heard Dad sing about 1 or 2 verses. Cat says she's still missing a verse about "that's our recommendation". Hopefully someone else can come up with it.) The Great American Bum Harry McClintock
Come, all you jolly jokers, and listen while i hum,
Oh, it's early in the morning 'ere the dew is off the ground
(this next part is spoken dialogue, with a woman who has a strong "Oirish" accent)
[knock! knock! knock!]
Good mornin, Mum!
Good morning, Bum!
Mum, could you spare a loaf of bread?
Go away, Bum, the baker is dead.
But, Mum, i've been walking all morning!
Honestly, Mum, wouldn't you have a bite to eat in the house?
Aye, that i would, Bum -- and a six foot Irishman comin' home at five o'clock to eat it! On your way, now!
Goodbye, then, Mum.
Goodbye, Bum
Oh, sleeping in the pokey, fogey-ogey-ogey
Here's some more verses from Tolbert Eldon Ashbrook
Oh it's early in the morning,
Here's a similar version emailed to me from Harold Recknagle
|