bowline vs. bow line in canal songs

02 May 08 - 09:26 AM (#2331247)
Subject: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Dave Ruch

Advice sought from a landlubbing Mudcatter who likes canal songs!

I have come across the word "bowline" in a couple of Erie Canal songs (A Trip on the Erie, The E-ri-o Canal). Yankee John Galusha, the only "source singer" I've heard pronounce the word, says it as "bo-line", but I understand that it would ordinarily be pronounced "bo-lin" on sailing ships. Galusha was not a sailor himself, so that could explain things if his is a mispronunciation. BUT, wouldn't a canal boat (19th cent) be more likely to have a bow line (two words, opposite of stern line) than a bowline? They didn't have sails for the most part.

The specific line from "The E-ri-o Canal" is: "Haul in your bowline boys, stand by you sorrel mule, low bridge duck your head don't stand there like a fool"

---

02 May 08 - 12:04 PM (#2331260)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: mack/misophist

From paintings and novels, one gets the idea that most canal boats were towed or poled. If the shore line allowed it, towing would surely be more efficient. You seem to have answered your own question. I'm no authority, though.


A bowline knot forms a noose, best known for not slipping and being easy to untie.

---

02 May 08 - 12:11 PM (#2331264)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: greg stephens

Wll, the knot is invariably pronounced bo-lin (in England). In the song "haul away the bowline" the rope is pronounced bo-lin.
But in canal circles, the actual rope is always(in my experience) pronounced bow-line as Dave Ruch suggests. people would look at you oddly if you yelled "Can you take my bo-lin". It's bow-line, and stern-line (or starn-line).. But this is now, in England. Then, on the Erie Canal???? Pass!

---

02 May 08 - 12:20 PM (#2331273)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Escapee

"Bo-lin" is a knot or a bit of rigging on a sailing vessel. A rope on the front of a vessel is a "bough(rhythms with cow)line"
SKP

---

30 May 17 - 09:55 PM (#3857990)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Joe Offer

In the Boy Scouts of America, where I learned to tie a bowline one-handed and became county knot-tying champion, the pronunciation was BO-lin.
I can't imagine saying it any other way.

-Joe-

---

31 May 17 - 02:13 AM (#3858003)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Just to make your life more difficult, the line attached to the bow, both on sailing vessels and canal boats in America is properly a bow line.

The knot is pronounced bo-line and the line attached near the midpoint of the leading edge of a square sail is pronounced bo-line.

When a sailing vessel is sailing into the wind, she is said to be on a bowline, pronounced bo-line. The engine that was once used all over the world was a Bolinder and the round thing on piers that lines were attached to to hold vessels to the pier was called a bollard.

---

31 May 17 - 03:03 AM (#3858009)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: DaveRo

I'd not heard "sailing on a bowline" - but I've never sailed a square-rigger. Seems to mean close-hauled, or possibly "sailing on the wind".

The important thing to know about the bowline knot - which I and most people I know pronounce bo-lin - is when not to use it. You can't undo it under tension. So if you tie your boat to the land with a bowline at the end of your bow line you may have to cut it to leave quickly.

the round thing on piers that lines were attached to to hold vessels to the pier was called a bollard.

They still are, aren't they?

---

31 May 17 - 09:17 AM (#3858098)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Mr Red

A minor point but when canal boats were pulled by horses the tow line (or rope) is usually attached to the post slightly forward of the centre of the boat. Llangollen horse drawn boats - the line is raised, it also helps avoid as much that might snag it.

Anyone who has steered a boat will know that (without bow thrusters) they turn about their centre of gravity - or if we are being pedantic, their centre of pressure. Boats pulled from the front (ie bow) will inevitably be veering into the bank and anyway are harder to steer.

Mooring uses bow and stern lines.

The post seems to go by the name of "mast" or "box mast". see also luby

---

31 May 17 - 02:25 PM (#3858159)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,ripov

Just to expand on Mr Red's post-


Dutch Barges and indeed those on the
Erie also fasten their towlines high and just in front of midships, but on the side to leave the boat clear.
Bow-line and stern-line are mooring lines.

---

31 May 17 - 08:33 PM (#3858222)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

I learned them as:

Bowline (bo-lin) - the piece of running rigging that controls a square sail's forward leech. A knot isn't required. An eye splice will do on a dingy or tender but usually a knot is tied to the sail's cringle. Not many 'bo-lins' to haul on the average canal boat.

Bowline (bo-lin) - also the preferred knot that originally took its name from the application. It is not a "noose". The "bight" or loop does not draw tight on a haul.

Bow line (two words, ie: bow & stern) a line used for mooring or maneuvering the forward part of the vessel. Bow and stern lines need constant tending in the locks. They should not be "made fast" or "dogged off" as in mooring.

Back where I come from:"Haul in your bowline [sic] boys, stand by you sorrel mule..." would be getting underway "up lock."

Mas minutiae:

Bollards: Were on the lock. Or wharf or whatevs.

Onboard:
Mast: Single, round, smooth
Post: Single, square, smooth
Bitt: Single or double with a crossmember (norman, cleat, &c)
Knighthead: Double bitt with a sprit.

"Bitting the tow line." - lead through a forward chock on the "near side" and thence to the bitt.

---

01 Jun 17 - 05:29 AM (#3858260)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Gibb Sahib

*weather leech

---

01 Jun 17 - 01:09 PM (#3858325)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Mr. Red, that's center of lateral resistance--just to be pedantic. And yes, "is" is correct about bollards.

The bowline [line] attaches to the sail by either a spliced in line on the weather leech or a rigid piece of wood [I have seen it] directly on the weather leech. In either case, the purpose of the intermediate between the bowline and the sail is to dissipate the strain on the leech. And yes, you do use a bowline knot at that end of the bowline.

---

01 Jun 17 - 01:46 PM (#3858336)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Ebor Fiddler

The Bowline on a Bight however is not far off being a noose ..

---

01 Jun 17 - 03:49 PM (#3858359)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: DaveRo

GUEST,Ebor Fiddler wrote: The Bowline on a Bight however is not far off being a noose ..

In what way? It acts much like an ordinary bowline - even harder to undo if under tension though.

I've occasionally used this knot (it puts a loop in the middle of a rope that is attached at both ends). In contrast, in years of sailing, I've never had occasion to do a one-handed bowline, though I know how to. Is this a climbers' knot?

---

02 Jun 17 - 03:32 AM (#3858414)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Mr Red

Mr. Red, that's center of lateral resistance--just to be pedantic.

to be truly pedantic the shape of the hull and the speed alter the centre of pressure, the centre of lateral resistance derives therefrom. Masts on narrowboats are central laterally and forward of the centre (howsoever defined). Towing speeds would not modify the centre of pressure by any noticeable measure. The shape of the hull might, who knows?

in the UK boats are 7ft beam (or <), barges (& broad beams) greater than.

FWIW I have put a few videos of Stroudwater renovation on my website canal.mister.red

---

02 Jun 17 - 06:29 AM (#3858442)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: bubblyrat

See you in Sidmouth, Mr Red ; ; I'll be on my honeymoon !

---

02 Jun 17 - 10:39 AM (#3858478)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Steve Gardham

Is there any connection between bow (as in throw) and bow (as in cow) apart from the fact that they're both spelled the same? If not this conversation is unnecessary.

---

02 Jun 17 - 10:42 AM (#3858482)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Yes.

---

03 Jun 17 - 04:22 AM (#3858589)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Mr Red

See you in Sidmouth, Mr Red ; ; I'll be on my honeymoon !

You may be busy! 😆

---

04 Jun 17 - 12:31 AM (#3858751)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Fossil

Not much to add to all this but.... (in no particular order)

It isn't practical to tow a boat along a canal (or anywhere else) with a line attached at the front - like that the boat steers itself into the side and the steersman has to correct it all the time, which is inefficient. Tow lines are attached at or near the mid-point and the boat tows just fine, with minimal corrections necessary.

A "bowline on a bight" in fact makes a very good noose - you tie a small bowline, which gives you a small loop that won't close up under tension, and then run the bight of the rope through that to make a larger loop, which will - a slip-knot. Put that around your hangee's neck and string him up, you'll soon see!

True you can't undo a bowline knot while it is under tension, but it is one of those very useful knots that won't tension itself into an undoable mass if it is under strain. Once the strain is off, you can always get it undone again, which is why it is so widely used on boats.

Mooring a canal barge or a sailing ship which has long straight sides is different to mooring a curved side vessel like a yacht. A barge needs just two mooring lines, usually - a bow line and a stern line are sufficient to keep it in place. The curved sides of a yacht need to be held in place by a bow line and a stern line to stop it rotating around the widest point, and then a pair of springs (fore and aft lines) to stop it moving forward and aft under the influence of wind or current.

Singers of songs aren't always experts in nautical usage, so one is likely to hear different variations of pronunciation. And poetic licence comes into it somewhere as well!

---

04 Jun 17 - 05:53 AM (#3858784)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Steve Gardham

Neatly put, Fossil.

---

04 Jun 17 - 11:03 AM (#3858839)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Almost right, Fossil.
The bowline is the strongest knot [as discriminated from splices] in that it will hold approximately 90% of the rated strength of the cordage it is tied in.
I have had a bowline in nylon line untie itself by slippage when wet. That resulted in two kids in a 28 foot rowing boat being stranded in the middle of New York Harbor until their towboat came back for them. That was one circumstance when a bowline was a bow line.
When I teach the knot, I always tell my students to put in an extra bight around the standing part, similar to an anchor hitch, in the line to make it more secure when it is likely to be wet, especially in polypropylene, nylon, Dacron or other synthetic lines.

---

04 Jun 17 - 03:54 PM (#3858894)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: bubblyrat

I had a two-year relationship with Her Majesty'S Sail Training Yacht, Merlin in the 1970's. She was built in Bremenburg in 1936 ,or thereabouts, as one of a fleet of 100- square- metre recreational yachts used by the German Nazi hierarchy for racing in the Baltic.
After WW2 , a number of these vessels were (joyfully !) appropriated by the Royal Navy of Great Britain , and called the "Windfall" class .Each carried 1000 square feet of sail on the one mast,Supported by "runner back-stays", which had to be deployed whenever she changed tack or went about ; the minimum crew allowed was 10 men ( or, sometimes, Naval Nurses !).My point about the bowline is that, when bending on the Genoa
,sheets, we always used the beautiful bowline, without which we would have been lost !
The bowline was always taught as the only safe way of putting a bight on a safety line if trying to rescue a "Man Overboard" situation , in the Royal Naval Seamanship Manual .
Alas, most Windfall-class yachts have ended up in Fiddler's Green along with their crews, BUT ; Merlin sails on as the Dutch Yacht "Zee Arend" ( Sea Eagle" ).Sadly, I do not know the Dutch for "bowline" (Het spijt mij !).

---

04 Jun 17 - 05:34 PM (#3858910)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: DaveRo

Interesting:
Windfall_class

There's also a youtube video:
Windfall Yachts - "Prizes of War" TV programme 1985

Proper sailing boats!

---

04 Jun 17 - 06:41 PM (#3858923)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

"Yee-hawing on the old Tamiami"

Most purpose built North American canal designs that I am familiar with had a modest height post or single bitt right up in the bows. The main deck was given over to cargo hatches / holds (barges) or passenger accommodations (packets.)

Lateral force is inverse to the length of the haul but she's always trying to "climb the hill" to some extent. Balance was achieved by "bitting" to the near side (giving offside helm) and a great barn door of an out-hung rudder.

One can also fashion a noose from an eye splice but an eye splice is not a noose. If you add a wheel it is a unicycle.

---

04 Jun 17 - 07:09 PM (#3858928)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Fossil

An interesting bit about the "Windfall" yachts - many years ago now, in the early 'nineties, my wife and I went from south Holland to Denmark in our 27 foot yacht "Evette". Up through Amsterdam, to Terschelling, where we made the decision to continue onwards, to Cuxhaven, Brunsbuttel and through the Kiel canal to Kiel itself, where we had a superb couple of days rest at the British Army Yacht Club in the Kiel Fijord.

This Club, which was run on behalf of all the service personnel in Germany was the beneficiary of most of the Windfall yachts, some of which were later returned to their former owners. But the Club facilities were superb and the staff and members were very welcoming to all British-flagged yachts. On our first night there, we went for a meal at the restaurant, got chatting to some local Brits and a Dutch couple who were alongside us, got very merry, then the guitars came out...

I have only good memories of that place, now in private hands, alas after the economy measures of later years required it to be sold off.

---

05 Jun 17 - 05:52 PM (#3859116)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Good video, DaveRo!

---

06 Jun 17 - 04:32 AM (#3859173)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Mr Red

Dutch for bowline is paalsteek

Dutch for bow line is boog lijn

according to babelfish.

---

15 Jul 19 - 12:50 AM (#4000769)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

In French "bout" is the pointy end but bouline has a more varied usage than the English.

Courir la bouline was the sailor's version of "running the gauntlet." A "gat" is a narrow strait or passage, ie: gate or gut.

A bouliner was a petty thief, goldbrick or such; typically bound for modern day Kitchen Patrol (KP) duty. More serious convicts were the chiourme (the choir) and galien (galley slaves.)

Fwiw: The marines' gauntlet was "passer par les baguettes" which isn't as tasty as it might sound. A marine's baguette was the brass, iron or hickory ramrod for his musket.

---

15 Jul 19 - 07:41 PM (#4000889)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Mrrzy

Nooses tighten, is why those knots aren't nooses?

---

17 Jul 19 - 06:13 AM (#4001002)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Jerry

I remember learning to tie a bowline knot in the Scouts. You soon learnt because it was the only way of abseiling down a vertical rock face with just a single rope and surviving. Not allowed any more of course on health and safety grounds, and they all sit in pre-formed bum cradles instead - a bit like using digital tuners instead of developing a musical ear, or venturing beyond the first five frets without a capo, I suppose. Do I get a prize for the worst thread creep ever?

---

18 Jul 19 - 03:30 PM (#4001123)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: WalkaboutsVerse

I only know the bowline as useful for drunken sailors:

"Heave him by the leg with a running bowline"

---

18 Jul 19 - 04:35 PM (#4001137)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

Nooses, running bowlines &c – The diameter of a properly tied bowline's "eye" will remain fixed. The drawn noose is the “running” part added by passing the standing end through the finished eye.

Unless that eye is unusually small, and/or the drunken sailor caught about the thigh, the running bowline will pass straight through its own eye and capsize itself into a type of hitch - tête d'alouette - lark's head, cow, girth, ad nauseum.

The running noose part will be gone but the diameter of the bowline's eye unchanged.

---

18 Jul 19 - 05:02 PM (#4001140)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: WalkaboutsVerse

You're not a rocket scientist, by chance, are you Phil?

---

19 Jul 19 - 12:32 PM (#4001200)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

If you look at a cargo net, it becomes clear that the netting hitch is the same as a bowline made up from two lines.

The reason the towline post on canal boats is near midships is that the further forward the post is, the greater the force drawing the bow toward the bank of the canal and the greater the effort the boatman has to exert to counteract this force. This also makes the mule work harder to pull the boat.

When I teach sailing, I make sure my students look at the water around the rudder. The water in front of the rudder builds up a "bow wave" and the water behind the rudder is at a slightly lower lever due to cavitation [turbulence] caused by negative pressure. If you have read any nautical novels, you have probably noted the instruction to "steer small." Now you know why.

---

20 Jul 19 - 09:06 PM (#4001323)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

Pedant maths:

“The reason the towline post on canal boats is near midships is that the further forward the post is, the greater the force drawing the bow toward the bank of the canal and the greater the effort the boatman has to exert to counteract this force.”

It's two systems. Do the math for tow angles of 0 & 90°, any loading. Moving the post (load) fore and aft doesn't change the basic geometry of the force vector triangle.

The vessel balances (pivots) on its center of lateral resistance. Like a see-saw, moving the load doesn't change the load. It takes less rudder effort because it's the same load on a shorter lever.

Midships posts produce much the same advantages in turns as nearside bitting in straight runs. Typical of boats, there are advantages and trade-offs to all the options.

---

20 Jul 19 - 11:54 PM (#4001330)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: EBarnacle

Exactly, Phil. The critical location is the center of lateral resistance [clr]. If you were to ask any naval architect, they would tell you that putting the center of effort [ce] too far forward of the clr would cause the boat to be pulled toward the bank. That is why the clr on a sailboat is located just forward of the ce. If you have ever tried to tack a boat in which the ce is aft of the clr, you would understand this.

---

22 Jul 19 - 12:45 AM (#4001506)
Subject: RE: bowline vs. bow line in canal songs
From: Catfeet

Having grown up on the Erie Canal (it was where all the crazy parties were held), I can confirm that they used tow lines to pull the boat and bow lines to dock it up to the side of the canal at scheduled stops, and at the locks. At the locks, they had to unhitch the mules to walk the incline while the boat was being lowered or raised. Who knew I had that bit of nautical knowledge in my brain?! Both the present day rides and the older pictures tell/show this. The things you don't know that you know...

---