To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=126340
17 messages

Tuning question ???

07 Jan 10 - 11:47 PM (#2806267)
Subject: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,erbert

Hello, I often see sets of guitar strings advertised with an "Extra high E string"

so how would that extra high E string be tuned then ?

one or two, or maybe even three octaves up from standard tuning ?

What kind of weird music would you play with that odd specialised tuning ?


07 Jan 10 - 11:52 PM (#2806268)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,999

I am guessing what you have already considered. It would maybe be a way-far lighter guage string that can then be tuned an octave higher than the normal high e-string. It would likely be used by lead guitarists to hit extremely high notes in solos.


08 Jan 10 - 12:01 AM (#2806271)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: Ross Campbell

If you divide up the words like this "an extra high-E string" you will find the solution (as would checking the pack of strings). You will have seven strings, two of which will be high-E. Provided to allow for more frequent breakage on the lightest-gauge string.

Ross


08 Jan 10 - 12:03 AM (#2806272)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,999

LOL. Dang, did I miss on that or what? Thanks, Ross. LOL.


08 Jan 10 - 12:08 AM (#2806276)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: michaelr

Jeez, guys...


08 Jan 10 - 12:10 AM (#2806279)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,999

Jaysus, Michael, the 1960s, ya know? LOL


08 Jan 10 - 12:14 AM (#2806281)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,999

Don't ya love it when yer a complete idiot. LOL.


08 Jan 10 - 11:08 AM (#2806641)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,leeneia

Yeah,but usually when I break a string, it's the D. A guy in a music store said that's because it's the string we play the most.

What's your experience?


08 Jan 10 - 11:17 AM (#2806648)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: greg stephens

I am with Leeneia on this. When I buy a set, I get an extra D to be on the safe side. I never break top E strings(in fact, I suspect I very rarely play that string).


08 Jan 10 - 11:20 AM (#2806652)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: beeliner

"It would maybe be a way-far lighter guage string that can then be tuned an octave higher than the normal high e-string."

The break point would be the same regardless of the gauge.

But poster Ross is correct, it's an additional string - the wording IS somewhat ambiguous though.


08 Jan 10 - 11:23 AM (#2806655)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: olddude

Took my old Alvarez to get a new saddle put in, the guy said you don't want those real heavy strings ... I said no I want Martin Medium gage. He said, yea those are the really heavy ones why would anyone use them !!.. I said it is an acoustic guitar and I finger pick, what is "Heavy" about a Martin medium that is recommended by the guitar manufacturer. Mine you, this was a local repair guy cause I didn't want to drive an hour and half to the guy who did my Martin ...

I figured I better just take the guitar back home, he wasn't going to help me any ... Good grief ...


08 Jan 10 - 11:24 AM (#2806656)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: Will Fly

I always buy strings in singles - and get extra Gs and Ds. Luckily my local supplier does Elixirs in singles.


08 Jan 10 - 11:45 AM (#2806673)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: The Sandman

with breaking strings ,is it not more a question of which strings you retune are the most likely to break.
I have one guitar tuned in standard and also use this for drop d,and another guitar tuned either dgdgbd dgdgcd dadgbd,if you switch between dadgad dadeae,my experience tells me the g string is in danger of snapping.


08 Jan 10 - 12:59 PM (#2806728)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: GUEST,Ray

I've always put string breakage down to it being the string with the thinnest core - i.e. the plain steel part of the string. I tend to break "Gs" which have a thinner core than the top "Es". I suspect those of you who tend to break "Ds" are using very light sets with unwound "Gs".


08 Jan 10 - 01:09 PM (#2806742)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: DonMeixner

Yup, what Ray said. I use Martin Bronze lites. Basically the 80/20 bronze strings on My FG 180, Guild F -30, Martic JC 16, Alvarez D something or other, and Blueridge BR 43. I have not broken a guitar string in easily 10 years. All this instruments have been used in a band setting so I have worked those strings hard.

I am more likely to brak a banjo or bouzouki string and I break less than one a year of those.


09 Jan 10 - 07:15 AM (#2807376)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: alex s

Will, I break (very occasionally) the G string and I use Elixirs too - who is your single string supplier, please.

P.S. to others:
check out Will's playing on Youtube - he's an ace!

alex s


09 Jan 10 - 07:30 AM (#2807385)
Subject: RE: Tuning question ???
From: kendall

Remember when Mapes gave you extra high E, B and G strings?
They were crap but it looked like a deal.