To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=129934
14 messages

BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back

03 Jun 10 - 12:28 AM (#2919568)
Subject: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

This is actually song related, but I got myself in a pickle at work by reciting a story i can't source, and searching for it on Google has not panned out:

When i was a volunteer DJ I heard an album of alternative music where one of the songs was about a real artist, either realist or surrealist is hard to say:

The artist was at home with his son. The son was doing a painting of the back yard. The artist asked him why he (the boy) had left out the tree in the back yard. The boy looked at his drawing and said "hey, I DID leave a tree out of the drawing."

Whereupon the artist went out in the back yard with an axe and chopped down the tree.

This is supposed to be a true story but I can't locate it. Any ideas?


03 Jun 10 - 04:30 AM (#2919630)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: Crow Sister (off with the fairies)

Ooh, what a creepy way to mess with a kids head.


03 Jun 10 - 11:00 AM (#2919760)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: frogprince

Weird. How would you interpret something like that? Was the father so obsessed with strict realism in painting that he felt the need to teach his son what he considered to be an important lesson? Or was he just so mentally incoherrant that there is no way to guess what he was thinking?


03 Jun 10 - 11:02 AM (#2919765)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: mousethief

Hey, I did leave out a family of refugees from my painting....

I hope this isn't true.


03 Jun 10 - 03:53 PM (#2919955)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

This is something that fascinates me because it is supposed to be true and as you say, is unusual to say the least. Anyone with a background in art of the last hundred years?
It happened no earlier than the late nineteenth century, and I'm pretty sure it was European, French, German, Belgian, one of those countries.


03 Jun 10 - 04:10 PM (#2919968)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: gnu

Life imitating art?


03 Jun 10 - 10:28 PM (#2920213)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

Precisely. I'm wracking my brains. I'm almost ready to go through my alternative cd collection of about 400 disks and review all the lists. This has gotta jog someone's memory. Who was that artist. He's well known but not a 'name'.


04 Jun 10 - 01:59 AM (#2920285)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: Jim Dixon

This is a song you're asking about, right?

So shouldn't this thread be in the music section?


04 Jun 10 - 02:25 AM (#2920293)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: Amergin

There's a story behind the song....You know, I have heard the story, too...but I can't remember where....been trying to find it...but have been unsuccessful...


06 Jun 10 - 12:48 PM (#2921803)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

Well, there IS a song, but it's alternative, not folk, and maybe this should be above the line, except that I thought the odds were against finding the song even more than the story. I've got about 200 CDs to go through and the name of the band might not trigger my memory.


06 Jun 10 - 03:29 PM (#2921907)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: Charley Noble

Rather than chop down the tree, the artist could have just asked the tree "to leave"!

Leaving,
Charley Noble


06 Jun 10 - 07:05 PM (#2922029)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

Okay, I'm going home and looking for that album. Tomorrow I'm going to call the Fine Arts Museum we have in town and see if there's someone can help me out. I'll call back to Boston if I have to, SOMEONE's going to have this data in their memory banks!


07 Jun 10 - 08:26 PM (#2922759)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

Didn't find it last night.


08 Jun 10 - 04:02 PM (#2923338)
Subject: RE: BS: ARTIST who chopped the tree in the back
From: robomatic

Went through about eighty CDs and rapidly lost enthusiasm for the enterprise. I can't recall the alternative group or the name of the song, and since my alternative collection is a portion of the CDs i was listening to for the radio station i was volunteering in, I may not actually have it.

I've called two art museums and I'm going on line looking for forums where people talk about art.

sooner or later it will crop up.