To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=150067
59 messages

BS: Palm Sunday Greeting

24 Mar 13 - 04:50 PM (#3494331)
Subject: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting -jts
From: Jack the Sailor

May the spirit of this holy occasion, the warmth of the season make your heart bloom with joy & happiness, have a blessed Palm Sunday.


24 Mar 13 - 05:03 PM (#3494336)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: maeve

Thank you, Jack. The same to you.


24 Mar 13 - 06:26 PM (#3494351)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,Eliza

Thank you from me too! But regarding 'the warmth of the season', it's blooming cold here in Norfolk UK. Spring seems light years away! (I've always seen Palm Sunday to be a rather solemn occasion and the start of the momentous events of Holy Week. Today in church 49 verses of the Gospel were read with quiet sadness and respect. We weren't being joyous, instead we were feeling Jesus' pain and humiliation. Perhaps Easter Day is a more appropriate time for joy?)


24 Mar 13 - 06:33 PM (#3494356)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Jack the Sailor

How can you be said when you know the outcome? :-)
)


24 Mar 13 - 06:34 PM (#3494357)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

Hi, Eliza -

Palm Sunday is an interesting mix of emotions, as is Maundy Thursday. Both services start out with a joyous tone, and then end up very somber. Seems to reflect real life - it's never pure joy, and never pure sorrow.

And this week gives us a chance to do some of our best music.

-Joe-


24 Mar 13 - 06:40 PM (#3494361)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,mg

when did the ass all of a sudden become a colt?


24 Mar 13 - 07:57 PM (#3494392)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: McGrath of Harlow

They must be using a dodgy translation up your way mg. An she-ass, accomnoanied by a foal is what the Gospel says. Some translations call the foal a colt (which is not the normal term for a young donkey), but there's no suggestion Jesus is riding on the poor little thing. He's on the mother.


24 Mar 13 - 08:09 PM (#3494396)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: mg

they switched the gospel at whim. Also I want to a funeral rosary and they picked and swapped some sorrowful, joyful etc..mixed them all up. it is just not kosher.


24 Mar 13 - 09:00 PM (#3494409)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Rapparee

Yeah, and they threw in some new thing called "The Luminous Mysteries."

Me, I celebrate all during Lent. I even celebrate on Good Friday. If you're Christian you should too -- Jesus of Nazareth died that day to save us!


24 Mar 13 - 09:18 PM (#3494416)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

mg, the translation of the scriptures used in the Mass in the U.S. has been the same since 1999, but the Passion read on Palm Sunday changes on a three-year rotation - Matthew, Mark, and then Luke this year (same with a number of churches that use the Common Lectionary). There are differences in the text of these three "synoptic" (with one eye) Gospels, but the story is very much the same in all three.

But yeah, sometimes it's ass, sometimes foal, sometimes colt.

-Joe-


24 Mar 13 - 09:51 PM (#3494428)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Rapparee

My Bible out here says that he told the disciples that they'd find in town a strawberry roan that no one could ride and to bring it to him. If the owner asked what was going on, they were to tell him that that strawberry roan was finally gonna be rode.


24 Mar 13 - 10:03 PM (#3494437)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

Oh, that strawberry roan...


25 Mar 13 - 06:15 AM (#3494526)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: gnu

In Strawberry Fields?

hat, coat


25 Mar 13 - 06:32 AM (#3494538)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,Eliza

Hello Joe!
Agree about the music. But our church is sometimes a bit 'happy-clappy' so to my great disappointment we didn't sing 'Ride on, ride on in Majesty' or 'My song is Love Unknown', both of which I really like. The former was sung that evening on Songs of Praise on BBC TV, so I did at least hear it. We had some modern stuff instead. I suppose it's alright, and the vicar chooses it to attract the younger folk to church. However, there were only twelve of us there, nobody under about seventy, shivering with cold and watching our frozen breath rise like incense into the air!
The sombre aspect for me is engendered by the fickleness of the crowd, "Hosanna!" one minute and "Crucify Him!" the next. Not to mention the shuttling backwards and forwards of Jesus between Herod and Pilate, the demands for magic tricks by the former and the mockery of the Roman guards. And Jesus knew He was to die, He had to master his terror and try to get some courage from somewhere. I find Holy Week a roller coaster of emotion, only feeling joy on Easter Day itself.


25 Mar 13 - 06:34 AM (#3494539)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,Eliza

Forgot to mention that there are never any flowers, hangings, decoration or colour in our church throughout Lent and all this week. Just deepest purple. So the sombre atmosphere is even reflected in the surroundings.


25 Mar 13 - 10:27 AM (#3494629)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,Musket sans cookie

I wished my mate a happy palm Sunday in the pub last night.

He said for him every Sunday is palm Sunday. I suppose it is since his missus left him.

Hat. Coat. take II


25 Mar 13 - 10:39 AM (#3494634)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Keith A of Hertford

In the service I was at, it was pointed out that only Matthew told of palm leaves being strewn in His path.
Luke says it was coats.

I'll get me frond.


25 Mar 13 - 03:28 PM (#3494752)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST,mg

I could never get into being happy or sad on command. Couldn't be happy on Christmas because before you know it Jesus had to die on the cross. We were so filled with misery in Lent that by the time Easter came around we couldn't shake it. I don't remember Easter as being all that happy or festive although we were told it was supposed to be. Honestly, there was one day a year that all misery was suspended, except for remembering your poor ancestors in the potato famine, and that was St. Patrick's Day. Lent was suspended. Friday was suspended if it happened on Friday. I actually like Good Friday. I take the day off and go to the stations of the cross in an old church in Astoria. You get a plenary indulgance if you go to the stations on Good Friday. I do it as an insurance policy every year.


25 Mar 13 - 10:53 PM (#3494905)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Rapparee

Surprised the Pastor and went to confession -- first time since July 4, 1964. That was before he was born.


26 Mar 13 - 02:32 AM (#3494958)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

I hope you enjoyed confession, Rap. Last time I went, we concluded with a hug - the priest has been a friend for 30 years.

I have to say that during my seminary days, Holy Week was spoiled somewhat by term papers and midterm exams. Term papers had to be in before we left for home Easter Sunday morning after Mass - so Holy Saturday was often an all-nighter for me.

When you think back on the "good old days" of high school and college, do you ever remember how stressful it was? I like Holy Week much more now that I'm an adult with no responsibilities (come to think of it, my income taxes are due soon....)

Easter sunrise service on the shore of Lake Michigan, was always a memorable event for me (and I usually had my papers done by then).

-Joe Procrastinator-


26 Mar 13 - 09:51 AM (#3495057)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Rapparee

I confessed to being the Zodiac Killer, Jack the Ripper, and the St. Valentine's Day Massacre. He didn't believe me. I told him I sold drugs and porn to children and retired nuns. He still didn't believe me. It didn't end with a hug, but he did thank me for the six-pack of IPA I brought him.


26 Mar 13 - 11:03 AM (#3495085)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Nigel Parsons

Let's see it from the donkey's point of view (G K Chesterton)

When fishes flew and forests walked   
And figs grew upon thorn,   
Some moment when the moon was blood   
Then surely I was born.


With monstrous head and sickening cry
And ears like errant wings,   
The devil's walking parody   
On all four-footed things.


The tattered outlaw of the earth,
Of ancient crooked will;
Starve, scourge, deride me: I am dumb,   
I keep my secret still.


Fools! For I also had my hour;
One far fierce hour and sweet:   
There was a shout about my ears,
And palms before my feet.



And best wishes to all at this blessed time.
I often think that there should be a final verse to 'resolve' that poem!

When forests walked, and fishes flew,
Though I looked rather odd,
But, at that time, I knew. I KNEW.
I'd borne the Son of God!

Nigel


26 Mar 13 - 11:25 AM (#3495088)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Nigel Parsons

There again, who am I to try and improve on the classics?


27 Mar 13 - 07:13 AM (#3495399)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: GUEST

It's 21C in Malaga Spain - great time to be here!!!!!


27 Mar 13 - 10:09 AM (#3495472)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: wysiwyg

♪♫♪B░E░A░U░T░I░F░U░L░B░L░E░S░S░I░N░G░S♪♫♪
╔══════════....๑ ƸӜƷ ๑♥๑ ƸӜƷ ๑....═══════════╗
ღ♥ღƸӜƷღ♥ღ Have A Lovely & Blessed Week. ღ♥ღƸӜƷღ♥ღ
╚══════════....๑ ƸӜƷ ๑♥๑ ƸӜƷ ๑....═══════════╝

~S~


08 Apr 17 - 06:46 PM (#3849552)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: keberoxu

Season's Greetings.


09 Apr 17 - 05:27 AM (#3849622)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

I am not religious as I am sure everyone knows by now but the ritual and traditions, particularly those of Russian Orthodoxy and Roman Catholicism in which I was brought up, will always remain special to me. I always say that religion is fine until you start bringing all that god stuff into it:-)

At Catholic junior school I learned how to make a cross out of a palm leaf and that is a skill I retain to this day! But the memory I treasure most, mainly because it reminds me of my Dad, is the Orthodox tradition of hitting people on the head, very gently of course, with twigs of pussy willow. What I cannot remember is the phrase chanted while performing the ritual. Must have been either Russian or Slavonic and was just two words repeated. Started with something that sounded like "veldaclos". May be a faulty memory anyway but can anyone cast any light on it? Joe maybe?

Cheers

DtG


09 Apr 17 - 09:03 AM (#3849647)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Steve Shaw

We always hoped to get the biggest palm cross. On Ash Wednesday the trick was to jerk your forehead just as the priest was smearing you with whatever that greasy substance was, the aim being to get the biggest smear in your class.

36 people murdered in Egypt today as they attended Palm Sunday Mass. 😥


09 Apr 17 - 10:42 AM (#3849655)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Senoufou

Dave, in the Ukraine, they say, "Ya ne byu, verba bye. Za tizhden." according to Youtube.
It means apparently, "I'm not striking you, the pussy willow is striking you!"


09 Apr 17 - 11:10 AM (#3849663)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: DMcG

Seasons blessings to those who care for such things, and general good will to the rest!

Musically speaking, I like "Gloria Laus and Honor tibi sit" as both the Gregorian chant and the lively verion performed by Royston and Heather Wood but the loose translation "All glory, praise and Honour to thee Redeemer King" has always been a bit dire in any church I have been in. Maybe it is the congregations I have been in but it tends to be slow, timidly sung and disorganised when the people at the front of the procession get out of time with those at the rear.


09 Apr 17 - 12:06 PM (#3849671)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Keith A of Hertford

We had two Kendrick hymns, Servant King and Make-way.


09 Apr 17 - 12:42 PM (#3849675)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: DMcG

One innovation I introduced to a church a few years back was Kendrick's "Majesty" at the end of Maundy Thursday but to ignore the "Triumphantly" instruction and sing it subdued and with sadness in the chorus. I have to say the congregation was in tears.


09 Apr 17 - 12:46 PM (#3849677)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: DMcG

Sorry I meant "meekness and majesty"


09 Apr 17 - 02:27 PM (#3849694)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: keberoxu

Palm Sunday was an upbeat occasion in the middle-of-the-road Protestant-merger denomination to which my family was faithful.

Dreary Palm-Sunday observances, in my experience, are High-Church rituals. The less ritual, the cheerier the spring sunday in question.


09 Apr 17 - 05:08 PM (#3849710)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Lanfranc

It is reported that followers of the "religion of peace" have ensured that Palm Sunday was celebrated in true peaceful Islamic fashion in Egypt at least.

Is this more false news? Or another wake up call!

Sorry to introduce a touch of contemporary reality, but someone has to.

Alleluia!

Alan


09 Apr 17 - 08:58 PM (#3849746)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

Many ethnic groups have an Easter greeting that goes like this:

a: He is risen, alleluia.
b: He is risen indeed, alleluia, alleluia.

Since I married a Polish Rhode Island woman and inherited a Polish Rhode Island mother-in-law, I'm used to hearing it in Polish.

Are there similar traditional ethnic greetings for Palm Sunday?

-Joe-

I"m sorry to hear of the bombing of Coptic churches in Egypt this morning. I visited a few Coptic churches when I was in Egypt. The people were so nice, and they were so proud of their religion and their traditions.


10 Apr 17 - 06:55 AM (#3849812)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

The word 'Verba' rings a bell and fits with my poor attempt at phonetics! Eliza - Thank you. I'll figure it out eventually :-)

DtG


10 Apr 17 - 12:56 PM (#3849868)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Steve Shaw

What happened in Cairo in no way represented mainstream Islam, Lanfranc.


10 Apr 17 - 01:41 PM (#3849879)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Lanfranc

I beg to differ, Steve. Just Google "violent verses in the Koran".

All religions are stupid, but only islam contrIves to be obnoxious, intolerant and supremacist as well.

Imagine no religion.

Alan


10 Apr 17 - 01:47 PM (#3849884)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Steve Shaw

That demonstrates an indigestible level of intolerance towards one and a half billion peaceful Muslims and it's an attitude that serves only to exacerbate the problems of the world. Choose your target more astutely.


10 Apr 17 - 04:32 PM (#3849908)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

Palm Sunday greetings to you, Lanfranc. I think people (and religions) get into trouble when they make sweeping condemnations, and even worse when they base violent action on those condemnations.

It's quite true that some members of most groups are guilty of such actions.

And yes, I suppose it's true that one can find stupidity, obnoxiousness, intolerance, and supremacist leanings in all groups - and perhaps in all individuals, including ourselves. But I think it's also possible to find wisdom and good in almost all groups and almost all individuals.

But sweeping statements are almost always wrong, as is yours.

-Joe Offer-


11 Apr 17 - 01:09 AM (#3849950)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: mg

For holy thursday google pange lingua by basque group mocedecos???.


11 Apr 17 - 01:27 AM (#3849952)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: mg

More like mocedades...they are so great.


11 Apr 17 - 04:07 AM (#3849956)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Keith A of Hertford

It has to be said that in recent years extreme Islam has had the monopoly on religious mass murders, the main victims being other kinds of Muslims and Christians.
Also, the perpetrators see themselves as mainstream even if we do not.


11 Apr 17 - 04:26 AM (#3849961)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Joe Offer

Here's Mocedades doing "Pange Lingua" in 1969: And in 1984: And in 2015: Here's a Mocedades concert from 2015. It starts out with an instrumental rendition of "Eres tu":I like what I heard of the concert.

-Joe-


11 Apr 17 - 04:53 AM (#3849968)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Steve Shaw

Yes Keith but WE know they are not mainstream because there are very few of them in one and a half billion Muslims. The very definition of non-mainstream. I really don't care how a tiny bunch of fanatics see themselves. And what a great idea it would be to keep anti-Islam advocacy out of this thread. I mentioned the killings with sadness because they happened as Palm Sunday was being celebrated, that's all.


11 Apr 17 - 04:54 AM (#3849969)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Steve Shaw

Thanks for those links, Joe. I'd never heard of them before. Great stuff.


05 Apr 20 - 07:57 PM (#4044240)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: keberoxu

okay, I got this a day late,
but better late than never.


23 Mar 24 - 07:47 PM (#4199612)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: keberoxu

refresh for 2024.
(One week after St. Patrick's [Sun]Day.)


24 Mar 24 - 04:37 AM (#4199625)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

I was inspired to look up the Russian phrase that my Dad used and I mentioned up the thread. At long last, think I found it!

See Verbohlest and ??????? ???????????

(Looks OK on my browser - Hope it is on yours!)


24 Mar 24 - 04:38 AM (#4199626)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

Ah, it doesn't now - The link still works though :-)


24 Mar 24 - 04:42 AM (#4199627)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

Oh, hang on, sorry, It doesn't. Look up "Pussy Willow Sunday" site:https://www.amazingrussian.com on Google and you should get there.

I've not had my breafast yet...


24 Mar 24 - 05:44 AM (#4199629)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Backwoodsman

The Verbohlest link worked for me, Dave, but not the other one.

Very interesting to read about a different ‘take’ on what we know as Palm Sunday - I rather prefer ‘Pussy-Willow Sunday’, and I like the idea of people whipping others with a Pussy-Willow twig as a form of well-wishing and blessing.

Thanks for that.


24 Mar 24 - 06:55 AM (#4199632)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

Tried DaveRo's Firfox extension on the wrong thread but it worked anyway :-) Thanks Dave

Pussy Willow Sunday


24 Mar 24 - 07:10 AM (#4199633)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

Prounced like this :-)


24 Mar 24 - 02:26 PM (#4199650)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: keberoxu

Just to say that today is a huge improvement over yesterday.
Yesterday it rained all day and froze at night.
Today the sky is blue, the clouds are white, the sun is out,
and it's beautiful to look at,
even though the trees are bare.
I spotted some crocuses this past week as well.


25 Mar 24 - 04:01 AM (#4199676)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Black belt caterpillar wrestler

We were out playing for the Bury Pace-egging play yesterday, always doing a tour of pubs on Palm Sunday and going back 50 years or so.
10 performances yesterday collecting for the Bury Blind society.

Robin


25 Mar 24 - 04:06 AM (#4199677)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Dave the Gnome

Were you Saint George, that noble champion bold
Who, with your trusty broadsword, won ten thousand pounds in gold?


25 Mar 24 - 05:21 AM (#4199682)
Subject: RE: BS: Palm Sunday Greeting
From: Black belt caterpillar wrestler

No, just the hangers-on providing the music.

We did have a smoke snorting dragon though! (A ventriloquist's dummy in a previous life).

Robin