To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=150075
9 messages

The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!

25 Mar 13 - 02:43 PM (#3494739)
Subject: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein)
From: Peter K (Fionn)

I've been searching for many years for this series of six Harvard lectures by Leonard Bernstein. It does exist as a DVD set, but only in Pal 1 format. Does anyone know where a copy compatible with Pal 2 can be obtained, or if there is any way of converting from Pal 1 to Pal 2?


26 Aug 20 - 05:52 PM (#4069742)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein)
From: Felipa

I can't answer Peter K's question (by the way, we met in person once, but I haven't seen him on Mudcat in years) but I think he would also be interested in this 44 min radio documentary I just listened to: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00007jy The Bernstein Files

"For more than three decades the US government compiled covert reports on the political activities and associations of legendary conductor composer, Leonard Bernstein. ...
...
"Investigative reporter Jonathan Coffey travels to New York and Washington to open the secret FBI files on Leonard Bernstein and ask why the US Government spied him for more than three decades. ..."


26 Aug 20 - 06:13 PM (#4069745)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein)
From: Steve Shaw

I remember hearing some of those lectures many years ago. Since then I've become an aficionado of Bernstein's compositions as well as of his music-making. I'd love to revisit those lectures. To my mind, in 20th century America, there's Gershwin, Bernstein, then the rest. Oh, and Woody...

Try the YouTube of Lenny conducting Beethoven's Leonora no. 3...


26 Aug 20 - 09:15 PM (#4069763)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein)
From: Joe Offer

The Unanswered Question is a lecture series given by Leonard Bernstein in the fall of 1973 Do I understand correctly that Bernstein took literature at Harvard from George Lyman Kittredge? That would make Bernstein one generation removed from Francis James Child, more or less.

Hope I have the time to follow all six lectures. It's intriguing. I listened to the first few minutes and then had to go, but it started out with a bang! Bernstein can be casual and erudite and ultimately cool at the same time. It's a pleasure to listen to him.

-Joe-


27 Aug 20 - 02:43 AM (#4069783)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!
From: DaveRo

That programme followed an old prom From 1987 of Bernstein conducting Mahler's 5th, which also is worth listening to.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p08kvnrv


27 Aug 20 - 10:20 AM (#4069844)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!
From: Stilly River Sage

When the original question was posted DVDs were a main way to get this kind of file and regions were the idea of producers to "protect" their content, now everything is converted to mp4 and is on YouTube. This is the Internet at its best. :)


21 Dec 21 - 03:15 AM (#4129530)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!
From: Joe Offer

Here's a link to a production of a recording of West Side Story, directed by Leonard Bernstein. It shows Bernstein at his most brilliant, but also he seems to be crabby and overly exacting. I imagine he might not have been an easy person to work with, but he certainly was a perfectionist.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3SEW63LsaM


29 Jul 22 - 05:09 PM (#4148683)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!
From: DaveRo

Well, two years after reading Joe's post about Bernstein's Harvard Lectures, I've now watched all 6. As the subject says: wow! (I downloaded them and they've been on a memory stick in the back of my last two TVs.) I've learnt a lot. And not only about music: in #6 he analyses poetry by E E Cummings and T S Eliot and draws parallels with Stravinski.

But I'd like a second opinion on many of Bernstein's theories and assertions. I wonder if other modern conductors could present a similar analysis? Do any current conductors have Bernstein's breadth of knowledge?

A few months ago, or maybe a few years ago, I watched a docu about Marin Alsop on Sky TV (here in the UK): The Conductor

I'm also part-way though LB's biography by Humphrey Burton, which I recommend.


31 Jul 22 - 07:47 AM (#4148836)
Subject: RE: The Unanswered Question (Bernstein) - wow!
From: Jack Campin

He was absolutely clueless about early music and wouldn't listen to any of the many people who could have put him straight.