17 Nov 19 - 02:37 PM (#4019837) Subject: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,SoloSongwriter Where along the folk spectrum does the solo work of Neil Young land? By this, I mean that I hear, in much of his early acoustic solo work especially, a much more independent musical streak, as opposed to much of his electric-band work, which seems to at least seemingly track with more established pop music forms. I am interested in whether anyone sees some of the hallmarks of the folk tradition in the writing and playing of Young in his earlier solo output. |
17 Nov 19 - 03:18 PM (#4019852) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Dave the Gnome I've heard "After the goldrush" and "The needle and the damage done" a few times at folk clubs. If that's any help! |
17 Nov 19 - 03:26 PM (#4019855) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: meself People understand very different things by the term "the folk tradition". You are unlikely to get a satisfactory response here unless you indicate what you mean by it - and even then, your understanding is likely to be challenged! Good luck. |
17 Nov 19 - 03:32 PM (#4019857) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Steve Gardham Probably right at the end furthest away from traditional song but if it is as DtG says sung in folk clubs in a folk style then millions of people would happily accept it as part of the spectrum. And then the absolute purists would say it can't be anything to do with the folk spectrum, but everybody's entitled to their opinion. Would you rather listen to the purists or the masses? Your choice. |
17 Nov 19 - 03:46 PM (#4019862) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,keberoxu Another song that would get away with it, so to speak, is "Old Man," with James Taylor's banjo obbligato. It is a song which is from his early albums yet has been reprised in recent years, and has received a sympathetic response. |
17 Nov 19 - 10:18 PM (#4019933) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,Pop hippie junk! I am not a fan. Nothing Young has done was any good to me except with Crosby, Nash and Stills. It was good in the 60s and 70s, today, not so much. a few songs are still okay, but pop, not folk. Folk tradition? Not. But then one of my good freiends was fired from being his archivist with huge unpaid back pay. Young is a puffed up old jerk. And I cannot stand his whiny voice unless he's in harmony with a real singer. My humble opinion. |
18 Nov 19 - 07:11 AM (#4020010) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: gillymor The only LP of Young's I still enjoy listening to is his second solo effort, "Everybody Knows this is Nowhere", some of the songs display a strong country music vibe like the title cut and "The Losing End". |
18 Nov 19 - 08:28 AM (#4020025) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Lighter What I find interesting is the widespread identification of the hallmark of "folk music" as being both instrumentally "acoustic" and stylistically "independent." |
18 Nov 19 - 09:26 AM (#4020036) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,Hi Lo I have never thought of Neil Young as a Folk singer. I think he is truly one of the giants of popular music. He has written icon song, Old Man, Cinnamon His version of all along the Watchtower is much better than Jimmie Hendricks' version. He has been writing about the environment for years, has written great political songs ,but what I admire most about him is that he was never afraid to change, to take musical and commercial risks. His album "Trans" takes him into the world of techno pop, fans hated it at the time, but it is now considered one of his best. But , to reiterarte, I never thought of him as a folk artists. |
18 Nov 19 - 12:21 PM (#4020084) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: peteglasgow i think his early stuff is a bit of country and a bit of folk - what we would now call americana. i wouldn't want to label any of us stuff though, very varied in style (on the beach? zuma? and other aforementioned efforts) and quality. i've always found him interesting and though, jack campin, i'm clearly thick when it comes to music i have found it pays to have catholic taste and to try not to be too judgmental |
18 Nov 19 - 12:36 PM (#4020088) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,HiLo Yes, there is a broad streak of country in early neil Young . There is however, something quintessentially Canadian about his writing, as there is in Joni Mitchell, Leonard Cohen, Stan Rodgers, Gordon Lightfoot and Bruce Cockburn, among others. They share an inward looking point of view quite often. Wish I could explain it better..but it is a feeling I get from many Canadian writers. |
19 Nov 19 - 05:57 AM (#4020280) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,Pseudonymous The man with guitar thing has to have been 'folk' influenced? Not arguing that he is folk, but 'broad streak' seems a good way to put it. |
19 Nov 19 - 06:01 AM (#4020283) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Allan Conn I am not sure how something would be good in the 60s and 70s - bot not today? For me if it is good then it is good no matter when it was recorded. |
19 Nov 19 - 06:05 AM (#4020284) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Jack Campin The "is it folk?" question is often like someone seeing a turd on the pavement and spending so much effort thinking about whether it's human, dog or dragon that they end up stepping in it. |
19 Nov 19 - 07:02 AM (#4020294) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Lighter Well, Allan, I might have thought something was great in the '60s and then decided many years later that it was - well, not quite junk, but not very interesting. This actually happened. But it's obviously true that one can like something from any period. |
19 Nov 19 - 08:19 AM (#4020310) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,Pseudonymous Round here it's mainly dog or human. |
19 Nov 19 - 08:55 AM (#4020324) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: Jeri I loved this song the first time I heard it. Thrasher Genres, in my opinion, help us find music we might like. They aren't any good for pigeon-holing songwriters or performers, or music, for that matter. |
19 Nov 19 - 02:58 PM (#4020408) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: The Sandman "Thrasher" They were hiding behind hay bales, They were planting in the full moon They had given all they had for something new But the light of day was on them, They could see the thrashers coming And the water shone like diamonds in the dew. And I was just getting up, hit the road before it's light Trying to catch an hour on the sun When I saw those thrashers rolling by, Looking more than two lanes wide I was feelin' like my day had just begun. Where the eagle glides ascending There's an ancient river bending Down the timeless gorge of changes Where sleeplessness awaits I searched out my companions, Who were lost in crystal canyons When the aimless blade of science Slashed the pearly gates. It was then I knew I'd had enough, Burned my credit card for fuel Headed out to where the pavement turns to sand With a one-way ticket to the land of truth And my suitcase in my hand How I lost my friends I still don't understand. They had the best selection, They were poisoned with protection There was nothing that they needed, Nothing left to find They were lost in rock formations Or became park bench mutations On the sidewalks and in the stations They were waiting, waiting. So I got bored and left them there, They were just deadweight to me Better down the road without that load Brings back the time when I was eight or nine I was watchin' my mama's T.V., It was that great Grand Canyon rescue episode. Where the vulture glides descending On an asphalt highway bending Thru libraries and museums, galaxies and stars Down the windy halls of friendship To the rose clipped by the bullwhip The motel of lost companions Waits with heated pool and bar. But me I'm not stopping there, Got my own row left to hoe Just another line in the field of time When the thrasher comes, I'll be stuck in the sun Like the dinosaurs in shrines But I'll know the time has come To give what's mine. |
20 Nov 19 - 10:15 AM (#4020473) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,HiLo Well, it may not be folk, but it sure is fine... Great lyrics, as are many Neil Young lyrics,one of my favourites is Don't let it bring You Down.. Sugar Mountain is great as well, but not very well known. |
20 Nov 19 - 08:36 PM (#4020619) Subject: RE: Neil Young solo work - folk tradition? From: GUEST,Pseudonymous Have to admit to a liking for that old Buffalo Springfield track with the neat guitar bit for paranoia (For What It's Worth). Yes I know Young did not write it. And 4 dead in Ohio … |